01
Best overall pick
The Pizzeria
North Ottawa • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Dine-In
A long-running Ottawa staple turning out generous pies with plenty of toppings and a true hometown feel.
The Pizzeria is the spot many locals name first when you ask where to go for pizza in town. The crust is sturdy enough for heavy toppings, and the menu usually has plenty of crowd-pleasers like loaded specialty pies and classic pepperoni. It is a comfortable option when you want a relaxed sit-down meal without leaving Ottawa.
02
Best for carryout
Padrone's Pizza
East Ottawa • Carryout-Focused Pizza Shop • Great For Weeknight Takeout
An Ohio-born chain spot known for reliable pan and thin-crust pizzas that travel well back home.
Padrone's is a go-to when you want a fast, hot pizza to take back to the house or hotel. The menu leans into hearty toppings, cheesy bread, and wings, so it is easy to build out a full meal for a group. Order ahead on busy evenings, as the place can get busy around dinner time.
03
Most familiar name
Pizza Hut
North Elm Street Corridor • Family-Friendly National Chain • Best For Families And Big Groups
Ottawa's Pizza Hut delivers the same pan pizzas, stuffed crusts, and wings locals expect, with plenty of space for a casual sit-down meal.
If you are feeding a mixed crowd, Pizza Hut is the safe bet where everyone already knows the menu. The Ottawa location offers a full range of crust styles, pasta, and sides, which makes it easy to stretch a few pizzas into a full family dinner. It is also handy for larger carryout orders on game nights or weekend gatherings.
04
Best regional destination
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
Findlay - Near I-75 • Lively Pizza-And-Grill Restaurant • Worth The Drive For Variety
A popular northwest Ohio mini-chain with big pizzas, deep menus, and a lively bar-and-grill atmosphere.
If you are willing to make the short drive to Findlay, Beer Barrel rewards you with everything from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty pies and gluten-free options. The dining room is set up for families and big groups, but the bar area makes it just as good for watching a game. With burgers, salads, and appetizers on the menu, it works well when not everyone in the group wants pizza.
05
Best for hearty delivery
Fat Jack's Pizza
Lima - Neighborhood Spot • Old-School Delivery And Carryout Joint • Great For Late-Night Cravings
A Lima favorite that piles on cheese and toppings, ideal when you want a heavier, old-school style pizza run out from town.
Fat Jack's is a name you will hear from northwest Ohio pizza fans who like a generously topped, slightly indulgent pie. It is primarily a carryout and delivery operation, so it is smart to order ahead if you are driving in from Ottawa. The menu usually includes wings, subs, and sides, making it a good one-stop shop for a low-key night in.