01
Best overall pick
Millie's Cafe
Ottoville Village Center • Lively Small-Town Tavern With Pizza • Local Favorite For Pizza And Wings
A longtime Ottoville staple where crispy pizzas share the spotlight with big baskets of wings and cold beer.
If you want pizza without leaving Ottoville, Millie’s is the obvious first stop. The crust is sturdy enough for generous toppings, and the pies land in that sweet spot between bar food and a proper sit-down meal. It’s a relaxed place to catch a game, split a couple of pizzas with friends, and get a feel for the local crowd.
02
Best nearby pizza pub
Padrone's Pizza
Kalida, A Short Drive East • Casual Pizza Pub And Carryout • Best For Groups And Game Nights
A small-town pizza pub known for its hearty pies, friendly staff, and easygoing vibe.
Kalida’s Padrone’s is an easy hop from Ottoville when you want a change of scenery without much driving. Expect well-loaded pizzas with a slightly chewy crust, plus plenty of shareable sides if you’re feeding a crowd. It’s the kind of place where team dinners and family birthdays feel right at home.
03
Best for takeout
Fat Jack's Pizza
Delphos, Along Us-30 • Carryout And Delivery Pizza Shop • Best For Takeout On The Way Home
A popular regional spot turning out generously topped, made-to-order pizzas ideal for grab-and-go dinners.
For Ottoville locals who commute through Delphos, Fat Jack’s is a convenient way to bring home a hot pizza without adding extra miles. The menu leans into classic Midwest comfort combos and doesn’t skimp on cheese or toppings. Order ahead, swing by, and you can be back in Ottoville with dinner in the box before it cools down.
04
Best for a night out
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
Lima, East Of Ottoville • Spacious Family-Friendly Sports Grill • Best For Big Menus And Craft Beer
A bigger, busier option with a full bar, TVs, and a pizza menu that runs from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty pies.
When you’re making a trip into Lima and want pizza with a full sit-down experience, Beer Barrel is an easy choice. The crusts are on the heartier side, built to hold a lot of toppings, and there are enough specialty combinations to keep regulars from getting bored. With plenty of seating and a buzzier atmosphere, it works well for larger groups and game-day outings.
05
Most familiar choice
Pizza Hut
Ottawa, County Seat Of Putnam County • National Chain Pizzeria • Most Familiar Option For Picky Eaters
A classic chain stop where you know exactly what kind of pan, hand-tossed, or stuffed-crust pizza you’re getting.
Ottawa’s Pizza Hut is the reliable standby when you’re feeding a mixed group and want zero surprises. The menu hits all the usual notes—pepperoni pan pizzas, breadsticks, wings, and value combos—so ordering for a family or team is straightforward. It’s not the most adventurous choice on this list, but its predictability is exactly what some nights call for.