01
Best overall pick
Donatos Pizza
Washington Court House • Ohio-Style Thin-Crust Chain • Reliable Local Favorite
Cracker-thin crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and smooth carryout make this the go-to pie for many folks around Pancoastburg.
Donatos in Washington Court House is a dependable stop when you want consistent, no-fuss pizza with that classic Ohio thin-crust bite. The menu leans into generous toppings and plenty of specialty combos, plus wings and simple sides for an easy group order. It’s especially handy for takeout on busy weeknights when you’re driving back through town on US‑62.
02
Best for a laid-back evening
Cardo's Pizza & Tavern
Washington Court House • Neighborhood Pizza Tavern • Sit-Down Slice And A Drink
A casual tavern setting where you can linger over thickly topped pies, cold drinks, and a small-town crowd.
Cardo’s has the feel of a local gathering spot, with hearty pizzas that land somewhere between tavern-style and classic Midwest comfort food. The crust has enough chew to stand up to extra cheese and toppings, making it a good pick if you like a more substantial slice. It’s the kind of place where you can take your time, catch a game on TV, and still walk out with leftovers for the next day.
03
Best tavern pizza and wings
Rusty Keg Tavern
Washington Court House • Lively Pub With Hearty Pizzas • Best For Groups And Game Nights
Known as much for its wings and pub vibe as its pizzas, Rusty Keg is a solid choice when you want more than just a quick carryout.
Rusty Keg’s pizzas come out hot, cheesy, and built for sharing alongside baskets of wings and fries. The atmosphere leans lively rather than hushed, so it works well for casual meetups, game nights, or a relaxed evening out after work. If you’re coming in with a group, ordering a couple of large pies with different toppings is the easiest way to feed everyone without overthinking it.
04
Classic comfort pick
Pizza Hut
Washington Court House • Family-Friendly Pan-Pizza Chain • Best For Families
A familiar option with pan, hand-tossed, and stuffed-crust pies that works well when you’re feeding a mix of kids and adults.
The Pizza Hut in Washington Court House is a straightforward choice when you want something everyone will recognize and eat without debate. Thick, buttery pan crust and classic toppings make it an easy fit for kids’ birthday dinners, team celebrations, or movie-night takeout back home in Pancoastburg. Ordering a mix of crust styles and a couple of dessert add-ons turns it into a full, low-stress meal.
05
Worth-the-drive small-town gem
Ben & Joy's Restaurant
Mount Sterling • Small-Town Family Pizzeria • Best For A Relaxed Road-Trip Meal
A long-running Mount Sterling spot where the pizza feels homemade and the pace is unhurried.
Ben & Joy’s has the kind of old-school small-town feel that makes a short drive from Pancoastburg feel like a mini outing. The pizzas are straightforward and satisfying, with plenty of cheese, familiar toppings, and a crust that holds up well for leftovers. Pair a pie with a couple of simple appetizers and you’ve got a relaxed, sit-down meal that still feels firmly local.