01
Best overall pick
The Pizzeria
Downtown Pandora • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Go-To Local Favorite
Pandora’s own neighborhood shop, known for generous toppings and friendly, no-rush service.
If you ask Pandora residents where they order from most, The Pizzeria is the name you hear first. The crust has a satisfying chew, the sauce leans savory rather than sweet, and the topping coverage is reliably generous. It’s the kind of place that remembers regulars’ orders and turns out consistent pies for casual weeknights or small gatherings.
02
Best for variety
Pisanello's Pizza
Bluffton Town Center • Cozy College-Town Pizza Shop • Great For Mixed Groups
A Bluffton standby with a broad menu of specialty pies, subs, and salads alongside classic pizzas.
Just a short drive east in Bluffton, Pisanello’s is a staple for both locals and Bluffton University students. The menu offers plenty of specialty combinations, from veggie-heavy options to meat-loaded pies, so everyone at the table can find something. It’s an easy choice when you’re feeding a crowd that wants more than just plain pepperoni.
03
Best for big appetites
East of Chicago Pizza
Bluffton East Side • Pan Pizza And Buffet-Style Chain • Top Pick For Families And Teams
Comforting pan pizza, big trays of breadsticks, and crowd-friendly deals make this a hit after practices and games.
East of Chicago in Bluffton leans into hearty, pan-style pies with plenty of cheese and sauce. Families appreciate the shareable sides and value-focused specials, especially when feeding hungry kids or an entire team. It’s not fancy, but it’s reliably filling and ideal when you want lots of food without overthinking the order.
04
Best for carryout night
Pisanello's Pizza
Ottawa Main Street Corridor • Takeout-Focused Pizza Shop • Reliable Family Carryout
Ottawa’s Pisanello’s turns out balanced, well-topped pies that travel well from oven to kitchen table.
For Pandora households that run errands through Ottawa, this Pisanello’s location is a convenient carryout stop on the way home. The crust holds up nicely in the box, so slices stay sturdy instead of soggy. Add in wings, breadsticks, and salads, and you can cover a full family meal with one quick pickup.
05
Best small-town classic
Fat Jack's Pizza
Columbus Grove • Casual Takeout And Delivery Spot • Late-Week And Game-Day Favorite
Thin-to-medium crust pies with a nostalgic, small-town feel that hit the spot on laid-back nights in.
Fat Jack’s in nearby Columbus Grove is the kind of place many northwest Ohioans grew up with: straightforward pizzas, familiar flavors, and plenty of cheese. It’s especially popular for Friday nights and game days, when quick delivery and big orders matter more than frills. Order a couple of large specialty pies and a side or two, and you’re set for the evening.