01
Best overall pick
Carmela's Pizzeria
South Dayton-Lakeview Road Near Park Layne • Family-Run New York–Style Pizzeria • Go-To Spot For Classic Pies And Subs
Large, foldable slices and friendly service make this the natural first stop when a pizza craving hits around Park Layne.
Carmela’s leans into generous New York–style pies, but the menu also covers subs, pastas, and other crowd-pleasers, so everyone at the table can find something. The dining room is casual and kid-friendly, and carryout is quick if you’re heading back to a nearby neighborhood. It’s the kind of place where staff recognize regulars and remember your usual order.
02
Best pizza-and-burgers pub
571 Grill & Draft House
Route 571 East Of New Carlisle • Lively Grill And Taproom With House Pizzas • Best For Craft Beer And A Hearty Pie
A busy roadside pub where thin, crispy pizzas share top billing with big burgers and an impressive draft list.
571 Grill & Draft House may be known first for its burgers, but the pizzas are a local surprise—crispy, well-topped, and substantial enough to share. It works well for date nights or meeting friends, with plenty of Ohio beers on tap and a menu full of bar snacks. Expect a wait at peak times, especially on weekends and game nights.
03
Fastest delivery near Park Layne
Domino's Pizza
South Dayton-Lakeview Drive In New Carlisle • National Delivery Chain With Lots Of Combos • Best For Late-Night Convenience
This Domino’s outpost is the reliable choice when you want hot pizza at your door without leaving the couch.
With online ordering and frequent deals, the New Carlisle Domino’s makes last-minute dinners and study sessions easy to feed. The menu goes beyond pizza with wings, sandwiches, and desserts, so you can round out a full spread without extra stops. It’s especially handy for Park Layne addresses that fall neatly within the delivery zone.
04
Game-night standby
Papa Johns Pizza
North Main Street In New Carlisle • Carryout-Focused Chain Shop • Best For Big-Group Orders
Steady quality and easy online ordering make this Papa Johns a go-to for feeding a crowd on short notice.
If you’re hosting a watch party or kids’ sleepover, Papa Johns’ mix-and-match specials make it simple to cover multiple topping preferences. The crust is soft and familiar, and the included garlic sauce is a local favorite for dipping. Order ahead for weekend evenings, when the line of carryout boxes can get long.
05
Worth the short drive
Enon Pizza & Company
Village Center Of Enon • Small-Town Pizzeria With A Cozy Feel • Best For A Relaxed Sit-Down Meal
A short drive from Park Layne, this Enon staple serves well-seasoned pies in a laid-back, small-town setting.
Enon Pizza & Company has the kind of lived-in charm that makes it easy to linger over a second slice and another round of drinks. The crust has a pleasant chew, and toppings are layered generously, from classic pepperoni to veggie-loaded options. Pair your pie with a salad or appetizer and make an evening of it before heading back toward Park Layne.