01
Best overall pick
Marsella's Pizza
Ridge Road Corridor • Classic Family-Run Pizzeria • Local Institution
Longtime Parma staple turning out square-cut, cheese-heavy pies that hit every nostalgic note.
Family-owned since the 1970s, Marsella's is the kind of place where the sauce recipe and the regulars have not changed much in decades. The crust is sturdy but not overly thick, built to handle plenty of toppings and that signature blanket of mozzarella. Call ahead on weekend nights; the phones get busy, and locals know it is worth the wait.
02
Best sit-down classic
Casamel's Pizza
State Road Strip • Red-Sauce Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria • Best For Relaxed Dinners
A Parma fixture where you can linger over a loaded pizza, salad, and a glass of wine in a low-key dining room.
Casamel's blends a neighborhood pizza shop with a full Italian menu, so it works as well for a casual date night as it does a family meal. The pizzas are hearty and saucy, with just enough char on the crust to keep things interesting. Pair a classic pepperoni or sausage pie with a big antipasto salad and plan to leave with leftovers.
03
Neighborhood favorite
P.Jay's Pizza
South Parma • Carryout-Focused Pizza Shop • Best For Takeout Night
Go-to takeout spot known for reliable pies, chunky toppings, and value-friendly specials.
P.Jay's leans into the Parma comfort-food playbook with thick layers of cheese, saucy wings, and subs to round out a pizza order. The crust has a pleasant chew and enough structure to stand up to heavier combinations, which makes their deluxe and meat-heavy pies local favorites. It is an easy choice when you want to feed a crowd without overcomplicating the order.
04
Hearty lunch hero
Napoleon's Pizza
State Road Near Ridgewood • Ohio-Style Pizza Counter • Best Value Slices And Pies
No-frills counter-serve joint turning out thickly topped Ohio-style pies and lunch-friendly deals.
Napoleon's is the kind of place where the pizza box feels heavier than you expect thanks to generous toppings and plenty of cheese. The crust skews toward classic Ohio-style: slightly thicker, soft in the middle, and cut into squares that are ideal for sharing. Swing by at lunchtime for specials that make a big pie one of the better values in the neighborhood.
05
Family-friendly crowd-pleaser
Antonio's Pizza
Near The Shoppes At Parma • Casual Dine-In & Delivery Spot • Best For Groups And Kids
Lively, family-oriented pizzeria offering a wide menu, from classic pies to pasta and wings, in an easygoing setting.
Antonio's balances consistency with variety, which is why so many Parma families default here for birthdays, team dinners, and casual nights out. The pizzas come in multiple crust styles, so you can keep everyone happy, and the menu is broad enough that non-pizza people still have options. Dine in for hot-from-the-oven pies, or use it as a reliable delivery choice when you are hosting a crowd.