01
Best overall pick
Fratello's Pizza
Parma Heights • Thin-Crust Neighborhood Pizzeria • Go-To For Locals
A cozy Parma Heights staple known for cracker-thin crust and plenty of fresh toppings.
Fratello’s is the spot Parma Heights residents mention first when you ask where they actually order their Friday-night pizza. The crust is thin and crisp without feeling skimpy, and they’re generous with toppings while keeping everything balanced. It’s a friendly, low-key place that works just as well for a casual dine-in meal as it does for a big family carryout order.
02
Classic Parma institution
Casamel's Pizza
South Parma • Old-School Italian-American Pizzeria • Best For Red-Sauce Traditionalists
A longstanding Parma favorite serving saucy, cheesy pies that feel straight out of a family kitchen.
Casamel’s has that lived-in Parma feel: a little retro, very welcoming, and serious about its pizza. Expect a sturdy crust, plenty of cheese, and a slightly sweet, old-school red sauce that keeps regulars coming back. It’s the sort of place where carryout boxes head to every kind of gathering, from game days to backyard parties.
03
Old-school favorite
Marsella's Pizza
West Parma • Family-Run Carryout Joint • Best For Family Takeout Night
Family-owned since the ’70s, Marsella’s turns out comforting, no-frills pies that taste like hometown pizza should.
Marsella’s leans into the classic Parma model: straightforward toppings, reliable crust, and portions that feed a crowd without breaking the bank. The menu sticks to the greatest hits, which they’ve had decades to perfect. If you’re picking up a stack of boxes for a big family get-together near Parma Heights, this is an easy, crowd-pleasing choice.
04
Best for big appetite
P.Jay's Pizza
Central Parma • Hearty Neighborhood Pizzeria • Great For Loaded Specialty Pies
Known for generous toppings and substantial pies, P.Jay’s is a favorite when you want a filling, shareable pizza night.
P.Jay’s leans heavy in the best way: think thick layers of cheese, plenty of toppings, and specialty pies that can double as a full meal. It’s especially popular for delivery to Parma Heights and nearby neighborhoods when nobody feels like cooking. Add in wings, subs, and salads and you’ve got a one-stop shop for feeding a hungry group.
05
Quick takeout go-to
Napoleon's Pizza
State Road Corridor • Casual Takeout And Delivery Spot • Best For Fast, Reliable Pies
A State Road standby that turns out consistently good, straightforward pies ideal for quick pickup on the way home.
Napoleon’s is the kind of place locals keep on speed dial for weeknights: easy ordering, fair prices, and pizza that hits the spot. The crust has a nice chew, the toppings are well-distributed, and the menu is broad enough to please picky eaters. If you’re driving up State Road from Parma Heights, it’s an easy stop to grab dinner without a lot of fuss.