01
Best overall pick
Penso's Pizza - Dover
Dover • Classic Carryout Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A no-frills hometown shop turning out sturdy, craveable pies that Dover and Parral folks have leaned on for years.
If you ask around for a go-to pizza near Parral, Penso's in Dover comes up quickly. The menu leans hard into classic toppings, generous cheese, and that slightly crisp, slightly chewy crust people remember from childhood parties. It’s the kind of place where you call ahead, grab your boxes, and head home knowing everyone will be happy.
02
Classic family favorite
Pangrazio's Pizza
North Dover • Sit-Down Family Pizzeria • Best For Families
A relaxed, family-friendly spot where big pies, familiar toppings, and friendly service make it easy to linger over dinner.
Pangrazio's is a comfortable choice when you want more than just a quick pickup. The crust is hearty, the toppings are piled on, and the booths are usually full of local families splitting a couple of large pizzas. It’s an easy drive from Parral and a reliable option when you’ve got a crowd to feed and time to sit and talk.
03
Most creative pies
Dola Jean's
Downtown Dover • Modern Detroit-Style Pizzeria And Bar • Best For Craft Pies And Drinks
A newer-school spot known for thick, caramelized-edged Detroit-style squares, inventive toppings, and a solid drink list.
For something a little different from the usual round pie, Dola Jean's is worth the short trip from Parral. Their Detroit-style pizzas come in deep, cheesy slabs with crisp edges and bolder flavor combinations than you’ll find at most small-town shops. It’s a fun choice for date night or catching up with friends over a couple of shareable pans.
04
Old-school local staple
Casamel's Pizza
Near New Philadelphia • Neighborhood Pizza And Italian Spot • Best For Big Groups
A long-running local joint serving straightforward pizzas alongside Italian comfort dishes in a casual setting.
Casamel's has the feel of a place that’s been part of people’s routines for decades. The pizzas are straightforward and satisfying, with well-seasoned sauce and a crust built to hold up under extra toppings. With plenty of other Italian favorites on the menu, it’s a good pick when part of the group wants pizza and others are craving pasta or sandwiches.
05
Best pizza with full Italian menu
Michael's Restaurant
Downtown New Philadelphia • Retro Italian Dining Room With Pizza • Best For Lingering Over Dinner
A classic Italian sit-down restaurant where the pizza holds its own alongside pasta, grinders, and old-school red-sauce favorites.
Michael's is the move when you want a proper night out but still find yourself craving pizza. The pies lean Italian-American, with a thinner, flavorful crust and plenty of classic topping combinations, and you can round out the table with salads and pasta to share. It’s a comfortable, slightly nostalgic room that suits everything from a casual date to a family celebration.