01
Best hometown staple
Pisanello's Pizza
In Pemberville • Small-Town Carryout Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Classic, crowd-pleasing pies that feel tailor-made for a Pemberville family pizza night.
This long-running Pemberville outpost of Pisanello’s leans into familiar comforts: chewy crusts, generous cheese, and toppings stacked the way locals like them. It’s the kind of place people call without even looking at the menu, whether they’re ordering a basic pepperoni or a loaded deluxe. Expect straightforward, good-value pizza that travels well and anchors many a small-town gathering.
02
Best for game-day carryout
Vito's Pizza
In Pemberville • Casual Delivery And Carryout Spot • Go-To For Big Orders
Toppings-heavy pies and hearty sides make Vito’s a natural pick when you’re feeding a crowd.
Vito’s in Pemberville is built for nights when you want plenty of food on the table with minimal fuss. The crust runs on the thicker side, giving their specialty pizzas and extra-cheese orders some real heft. Round things out with wings, wedges, or breadsticks and you’ve got an easy spread for a game, birthday, or impromptu get-together.
03
Most reliable nearby chain
Marco's Pizza
Woodville • Delivery-Focused Chain Pizzeria • Best For Consistent Delivery
A short drive from Pemberville, Marco’s delivers familiar, customizable pizzas with lots of combo options.
Over in Woodville, Marco’s is a handy option when you want something you already know how to order. Build your own pie with a range of crusts, sauces, and toppings, or keep it simple with one of their specialty combinations. It’s a solid, dependable choice when you’re splitting pizzas among picky eaters or ordering from the road on your way back into town.
04
Best classic in Bowling Green
Pisanello's Pizza
Downtown Bowling Green • Sit-Down And Carryout Pizzeria • Worth-The-Drive Option
A short hop from Pemberville, this downtown shop serves old-school pies in a relaxed college-town setting.
The Bowling Green Pisanello’s location gives you the same dependable pizza with the bonus of a livelier downtown atmosphere. It’s a smart move when you want to make a night of it—grab a pie, maybe a salad or side, and wander Main Street afterward. For Pemberville residents, it’s close enough to feel convenient but different enough to feel like a small outing.
05
Best indulgent favorite
Campus Pollyeyes
Near Bgsu Campus, Bowling Green • Lively College-Town Pizza Joint • Best For Stuffed Breadsticks And Late Dinners
Known for hefty pizzas and famous stuffed breadsticks, this BG staple is a fun, shareable option for groups.
Campus Pollyeyes skews more boisterous than a typical small-town shop, but that’s part of the draw if you’re coming in from Pemberville. The pizzas are rich and filling, with lots of cheese and toppings, and the stuffed breadsticks have a devoted following among students and locals alike. It’s the pick when you want a casual, slightly over-the-top meal that feels like a treat.