01
Best for takeout close to the valley
Valley Pizza Co.
Near Peninsula Along The River Valley • Casual Takeout And Delivery Shop • Go-To For Cabin Nights And Easy Dinners
A small, no-fuss spot locals rely on for hot, generous pies after a day in the valley.
Valley Pizza Co. is the kind of place you call when you’re checked into a cabin or rental and don’t feel like leaving the gorge. The menu leans classic—pepperoni, sausage, veggie—with plenty of toppings and hearty, shareable sizes. It’s especially handy for families or groups who want good pizza without a long drive or a sit-down wait.
02
Best post-hike pizza and beer
Winking Lizard Tavern – Peninsula
Peninsula Village Center • Lively Tavern With Pizzas And Pub Fare • Best For Groups After A Hike
A buzzy Peninsula standby where you can pair a shareable pizza with a deep beer list and trail stories.
Right in the heart of the village, the Winking Lizard is a natural stop after biking the Towpath or paddling the river. The tavern menu includes solid thin-crust and pan pizzas, easy to split alongside wings and appetizers. It’s noisy, casual, and welcoming—ideal when you’ve got a mixed group of pizza lovers, beer fans, and kids in tow.
03
Classic neighborhood favorite
Farinacci Pizza – Hudson
Hudson, Off Route 303 • Old-School Local Pizzeria • Family-Friendly Staple
A long-running local chain known for sturdy, cheese-heavy pies and a loyal following.
Farinacci’s Hudson shop is a quick drive from Peninsula and feels like the kind of pizzeria every town wants. Expect a slightly crisp crust, plenty of cheese, and traditional toppings done well, plus a few specialty combinations that regulars swear by. It’s a reliable choice for carryout on the way back through Hudson or a low-key family dinner.
04
Most iconic pizza worth the drive
Luigi's Restaurant
Downtown Akron • Historic Italian-American Restaurant • Iconic Akron Outing
A beloved downtown institution where the thick, cheesy pizzas feel frozen in the best kind of time.
Luigi’s has been drawing Akron-area pizza fans for generations, and Peninsula locals make the trip when they want something nostalgic. The pizzas are hearty, with a chewy crust, plenty of sauce, and a snowfall of cheese that’s become its signature. Go when you’re in the mood for an old-school sit-down experience, and expect a wait on weekend nights.
05
Best for fast, customizable pies
Master Pizza – Cuyahoga Falls
Cuyahoga Falls, State Road Corridor • Modern Regional Pizzeria • Best For Varied Tastes In One Order
A flexible spot where you can mix specialty pies, build-your-own combinations, and wings in one easy pickup.
Master Pizza in Cuyahoga Falls is a practical option when your group wants different styles and toppings without compromise. The menu ranges from simple cheese and pepperoni to loaded specialty creations with bold sauces and toppings. It’s an easy stop on the way back to Peninsula from errands or a night out, especially if you order ahead for carryout.