01
Best overall pick
Zeppe's Perry
North Ridge Road In Perry • Classic Neighborhood Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A reliable go to for classic pies, wings, and Italian American comfort food right in the village.
Zeppe's Perry is the spot many locals default to when they just want solid, familiar pizza without overthinking it. The crust is sturdy enough to handle generous toppings, and the menu covers everything from baked pasta to wings and subs, making it easy to please a mixed group. It is a straightforward carryout and delivery operation, ideal when you want dinner on the table fast after a long day.
02
Best for delivery to Perry
Rego's Brickhouse Pizza
Madison, East Of Perry • Casual Pizza And Subs Shop • Delivery Specialist
Hearty, topping heavy pizzas that travel well, with delivery routes that regularly run into Perry.
Rego's Brickhouse Pizza is a popular option when you want something a bit different from the usual Perry standbys but still need delivery. The pies lean generous on cheese and toppings, so a couple of larges easily feed a family or small crowd. Round it out with their subs and sides, and you have a full game night spread without leaving the house.
03
Best specialty pies
Hometown Slice Pizza Co.
Downtown Madison • Creative Specialty Pizza Shop • Best For Inventive Toppings
A small, chef driven pizzeria known for playful topping combos and well browned crusts.
Hometown Slice Pizza Co. is the place you go when you are in the mood to try something beyond pepperoni and sausage. The owners put real thought into their specialty pies, with combinations that lean into seasonal ingredients and bolder flavors. It is a short drive from Perry, and worth it when you want to make pizza night feel a little more like a night out.
04
Best crust obsession
Kay Jack Pizza
Madison Township Near I-90 • Artisan Takeout Pizzeria • Best For Crust Lovers
Slow fermented dough and careful baking make the crust the star at this takeout focused shop.
Kay Jack Pizza is built around dough that gets extra time to develop flavor, and you can taste it in the crisp, airy crust. Toppings stay pretty classic, but the quality and balance make even a simple cheese pizza feel dialed in. It is a great call for carryout on your way back into Perry, especially if you care more about texture and bake than sheer volume of toppings.
05
Best for feeding a crowd
Gionino's Pizzeria Madison
Madison Near Route 20 • Family Friendly Chain Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups
Big, shareable pizzas and family sized chicken and jojo meals make this an easy crowd pleaser.
Gionino's in Madison is a familiar name across northeast Ohio, and the Madison location is an easy reach for Perry families. The menu is built for volume, with large pizzas, fried chicken, and potato jojos that can cover a whole team or extended family. It is not fancy, but when you need to feed a lot of people on a budget, it is one of the most practical options nearby.