01
Best overall pick
Phase Two Pizza
Central Perrysville • Small-Town Takeout Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Compact and unpretentious, Phase Two Pizza is the go-to counter for fresh, generously topped pies right in the heart of Perrysville.
Locals know Phase Two as the reliable spot when you want pizza without leaving the village—think classic crust, plenty of cheese, and toppings piled on. The menu typically stretches beyond pizza into subs, wings, and other takeout staples, making it easy to feed a mixed group. Call ahead on busy evenings, as the small operation can get backed up when the whole town decides it’s pizza night.
02
Best post‑hike stop
Mohican Tavern
Near Mohican State Park • Casual Tavern With Pizza • Best For Hikers And Campers
A relaxed tavern just a short drive from Perrysville serving hearty pizzas that pair well with a cold drink after a day on the trails.
If you’ve spent the day at Mohican State Park, this is an easy, low-key place to refuel with a hot pizza and a laid-back atmosphere. Pies are built for hunger, with thicker crusts and plenty of toppings rather than delicate artisan styling. It tends to draw a friendly mix of locals and park visitors, so expect a casual crowd and straightforward, satisfying food.
03
Best family night option
Loudonville Family Pizzeria
Downtown Loudonville • Sit-Down Family Pizzeria • Best For Families
This classic small-town pizzeria in nearby Loudonville offers roomy booths, kid-friendly options, and shareable pies for an easy family outing.
A short drive from Perrysville, Loudonville Family Pizzeria fits the bill when you want more than carryout and prefer to linger over your meal. Expect familiar toppings, basic pastas, and simple salads alongside the main attraction: hot, cheesy pizzas sized for sharing. It’s the kind of place where staff recognize regulars and no one blinks if the kids get a little noisy after a day on the river or at the campground.
04
Best for classic pepperoni
Downtown Loudonville Pizza Co.
Main Street Loudonville • Classic Midwestern Pizzeria • Great For Takeout And Game Nights
A straightforward pizzeria right on Main Street that turns out dependable pepperoni and specialty pies ideal for takeout back to the cabin or campsite.
This spot leans into the basics: sturdy crusts, plenty of cheese, and the kind of pepperoni cups that crisp at the edges in the oven. The operation is geared toward carryout, so it’s easy to phone in an order and swing by on your way through town. It’s a handy choice when you’re staying nearby and want a familiar, no-surprises pizza to go with a ball game or campfire.
05
Worth-the-drive pick
Ashland Pizza House
Downtown Ashland • Old-School College-Town Pizzeria • Best For A Night Out
Set a bit farther from Perrysville, this long-running Ashland pizzeria rewards the drive with character-filled dining and well-loved pies.
When you’re ready to make an evening of it, heading up to Ashland Pizza House offers more of an outing than a quick pickup. The vibe mixes college-town energy with an old-school pizza parlor feel, and the menu usually covers everything from basic cheese slices to loaded specialty combinations. It’s a good option if you want to pair your pizza with a stroll around downtown Ashland or meet friends who live farther afield.