01
Best overall pick near Petersburg
Cocca's Pizza New Middletown
New Middletown, South Of Youngstown • Casual Mahoning Valley Pizza Chain • Closest, Most Reliable Option To Petersburg
A short hop from Petersburg, Cocca's in New Middletown is the easy weeknight choice for familiar, crowd-pleasing pies.
This Cocca's location feels like the local extension of a classic Youngstown family chain, with staff who recognize regulars by name. The menu leans into thick, cheesy sheet pizzas, baked wings, and Italian favorites that travel well back to Petersburg. It is especially handy when you want consistent quality without driving into the city.
02
Best for thick, cheesy slices
Cornersburg Pizza Poland
Poland Village / East Side Suburbs • Carryout Shop Known For Hefty Crust And Cheese • Go-To Carryout For Game Nights
Cornersburg's Poland shop turns out heavy, cheese-loaded pies that Mahoning Valley locals swear by for parties and big appetites.
If you like your pizza square-cut, with a generous layer of cheese and a slightly crisp edge, this is the spot. The Poland location is a reasonable drive from Petersburg and has the efficient, in-and-out rhythm of a true neighborhood carryout. Call ahead on Friday evenings; lines move quickly, but the demand is real.
03
Best downtown Youngstown stop
Avalon Downtown Pizzeria
Downtown Youngstown • Brick-Oven Pizzeria And Bar • Best Pick When You Are Already Heading Downtown
Avalon offers a more urban take on Youngstown pizza, with brick-oven pies, a full bar, and a lively downtown energy.
When your plans already include a trip into Youngstown, Avalon is the place to make pizza part of the night out. The crust leans thinner and crisper than many local spots, with toppings that range from classic pepperoni to more creative combinations. It works equally well for a relaxed sit-down dinner or a pre-event bite before catching a show or game.
04
Best for family dinners
Bruno Bros Pizza
Boardman Retail Corridor • Family-Run Italian-American Pizzeria • Top Choice For Big Groups And Leftovers
Bruno Bros is the kind of place where big pans of pizza and pasta feed a crowd without breaking the budget.
Set amid Boardman's busy shopping strip, Bruno Bros is an easy stop when you are combining errands with a meal out. Their pizzas are sturdy and saucy, with plenty of classic toppings and a crust that holds up well for take-home leftovers. Add a salad, some baked pasta, and a few orders of wings and you have an effortless family spread after the drive up from Petersburg.
05
Best upscale pizza night
Yosteria
Youngstown's Smoky Hollow Area • Modern Italian Wine Bar With Artisan Pizza • Date-Night Option For Food Lovers
Yosteria pairs thoughtfully made, Italian-style pies with good wine and a cozy, city-adjacent setting.
For a night that feels a little more special than standard carryout, Yosteria is worth the extra drive from Petersburg. The menu emphasizes well-balanced pies with quality ingredients, along with small plates and a curated wine list. It is a smart pick when you want pizza to be part of a slower, more lingering evening out rather than a quick grab-and-go.