01
Best overall pick
Romeo's Pizza
Lagrange Village Center • Ohio-Based Chain Pizzeria With Hearty Pies • Reliable All-Rounder For Carryout And Delivery
Thick, cheesy pizzas with a slightly sweet sauce make Romeo's an easy crowd-pleaser for most tastes.
This is the closest dedicated pizzeria to Pheasant Run, and it covers just about every classic combination you could want, from pepperoni-loaded to veggie-heavy. The crust runs on the thicker side, with plenty of cheese and toppings, so a couple of larges will feed a family without breaking the bank. It’s a practical choice when you want solid pizza fast without driving into the bigger towns.
02
Best college-town slice
Lorenzo's Pizzeria
Downtown Oberlin Near The College • Old-School Italian-American Pizzeria • Classic Pies And Slices In A Walkable Downtown
Lorenzo's serves foldable New York-style slices and whole pies that fit perfectly into a night out in Oberlin.
Head into downtown Oberlin and you’ll find Lorenzo’s busy with students, locals, and visitors grabbing big slices or sharing a pie. The crust is thinner and more flexible than what you’ll find in most chains, with a good balance of sauce and cheese. It’s a strong pick if you’re pairing pizza with a stroll around town, a concert, or a visit to the college.
03
Old-school local favorite
Santalucia's Pizzeria
East Elyria Neighborhood • Family-Run Pizzeria With A Retro Feel • Best For Nostalgic, No-Frills Pizza Nights
Santalucia's focuses on straightforward, well-made pizzas with a loyal local following.
This Elyria staple leans into tradition: simple toppings, generous cheese, and a crust that strikes a middle ground between thin and thick. It’s the kind of place where people have been ordering the same pie for years, and that consistency is part of the appeal. If you like your pizza without gimmicks—just hot, cheesy, and dependable—this is worth the slightly longer drive from Pheasant Run.
04
Best small-town carryout
Angelina's Pizza
Grafton Main Street Corridor • Casual Carryout Pizza Shop • Easy Option For Quick Pickup On The Way Home
Angelina's turns out well-topped pies and classic sides that fit busy weeknights perfectly.
Located right in Grafton, Angelina’s is the kind of place you swing by on your way back toward Pheasant Run. The menu sticks to familiar territory—pepperoni, sausage, deluxe combos—but does them with a slightly crisp crust and plenty of toppings. Add in wings or breadsticks and you’ve got an easy, one-stop dinner that travels well.
05
Best for big groups
East of Chicago Pizza
Wellington Shopping Strip Near The Fairgrounds • Pan-Pizza And Buffet-Style Chain Spot • Great For Families And Team Parties
East of Chicago is known for its thick, pan-style pizzas and flexible options for feeding a crowd.
If you’re coming from a game, practice, or a day at the fairgrounds, this Wellington spot is set up for groups. The pan pizzas are substantial, with a soft, bready crust and lots of cheese, and there are usually plenty of budget-friendly specials. It’s not fancy, but when you need to keep a table of kids or teammates full and happy, it gets the job done.