01
Best overall pick
Pizza Cottage - Pickerington
Hill Road / Clint Drive Corridor • Family-Friendly Dine-In Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A go-to Pickerington standby with generous toppings, plenty of booths, and a menu that suits just about everyone at the table.
Pizza Cottage is the kind of spot where teams pile in after games and families linger over big shareable pies. The crust lands in that sweet spot between chewy and crisp, with well-seasoned sauce and toppings that feel a notch heavier than typical chain portions. It’s an easy choice when you need reliable pizza, cold drinks, and a casual sit-down option in one place.
02
Best for game nights
Cardo's Pizza & Tavern
Olde Pickerington Village • Tavern-Style Pizzeria And Bar • Lively Hangout Spot
A bustling tavern with crisp-edged pizzas, a full bar, and plenty of TVs for catching the game.
Cardo’s combines a neighborhood bar feel with seriously solid pizza, making it a natural pick for evenings out. Expect tavern-style pies with a satisfying crunch, plus wings, subs, and other game-day staples. The roomy bar area and large patio give groups space to spread out when the weather’s nice or a big game is on.
03
Best cozy classic
Grapevine Pizza & Cafe
Refugee Road West Side • Cozy Sit-Down Pizza Café • Best For Relaxed Dinners
A warm, low-key spot where you can linger over classic pizzas, pasta, and a laid-back small-town vibe.
Grapevine feels like a long-established neighborhood cafe, with friendly staff and a menu that leans comforting rather than trendy. The pizzas are straightforward and well-executed, from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty pies, and many locals pair them with salads or baked pasta. It’s an easy choice for an unhurried weeknight dinner or a simple weekend lunch with the family.
04
Best for carryout and delivery
Flyers Pizza - Pickerington
Refugee Road East Side • Carryout-Focused Neighborhood Chain • Best For Feeding A Crowd
A dependable local chain turning out square-cut Ohio-style pies, wings, and subs built for takeout nights.
Flyers leans into convenience without sacrificing personality, with a pickup window and a menu tailored for families and groups. The pizza comes cut into party squares, with a slightly thicker crust that holds up well on the drive home. Add on wings, garlic bread, and dessert to cover the whole crew with one quick stop.
05
Best for creative toppings
Beyond Dough Pizza
Near I-70 And Sr-256 • Modern Craft Pizza Shop • Best For Trying Something New
A newer-style spot known for build-your-own combinations, bold toppings, and a focus on fresh ingredients.
Beyond Dough caters to diners who like to customize, offering a range of sauces, cheeses, and toppings that go beyond the usual pepperoni-and-cheese routine. You can keep it classic or build something adventurous with veggies, specialty meats, and drizzles. It’s a smart pick when your group wants different styles of pizza without having to compromise.