01
Best for delivery night
Romeo's Pizza
Wadsworth • Delivery-Focused Pizzeria With Inventive Specialty Pies • Best For Delivery And Takeout
A reliable go‑to for hot, generously topped pizzas that still taste good after the drive to Pigeon Creek.
Romeo's in Wadsworth is the easy choice when nobody wants to cook and everyone wants leftovers. The crust is sturdy enough to handle big toppings, and their specialty combinations go well beyond basic pepperoni. It’s a solid balance of convenience and quality, especially if you’re staying in Pigeon Creek and want dinner brought to your door.
02
Classic Akron institution
Guiseppe's Pizza
Northwest Akron • Old-School Neighborhood Pizzeria • Old-School Local Favorite
A long-running Akron staple known for hearty, cheese-heavy pies and a no‑nonsense, locals-first vibe.
Guiseppe's feels like the kind of place that has been feeding teams and families for decades, because it has. Expect thick layers of cheese, well-browned edges, and classic toppings done the way regulars like them. It’s a short hop east from Pigeon Creek when you want that nostalgic, Friday‑night‑pizza feel.
03
Best for craft toppings
Dewey's Pizza
Fairlawn/Montrose • Polished Sit-Down Spot With Creative Gourmet Pies • Best For A Night Out
A modern dining room where you can pair thoughtfully topped pizzas with a good beer list and friendly service.
Dewey's in Fairlawn is where you go when you want pizza to feel like dinner out, not just takeout. The menu leans into creative combinations—think specialty sauces, fresh veggies, and well-chosen cheeses—alongside familiar standbys. It’s worth the short drive from Pigeon Creek when you’ve got friends in town or want to linger over a pie and a pint.
04
Best for quick carryout
Regina's Pizza
East Akron • No-Frills Carryout Pizzeria • Best Budget-Friendly Option
A straightforward, family-run spot turning out saucy, satisfying pies that won’t stretch your budget.
Regina's keeps things simple: generous pies, familiar toppings, and a focus on getting hot pizza into your hands quickly. The crust runs on the softer, saucier side, which makes it crowd-pleasing for kids and game nights. If you’re coming from the east side back toward Pigeon Creek, it’s an easy detour to grab dinner on the way home.
05
Best sit-down Italian
Lembo's Ristorante & Pizzeria
High Street Corridor, Wadsworth • Classic Italian Family Restaurant With Pizza • Best For Families And Groups
A retro Italian spot where pizza shares the spotlight with big plates of pasta, salad, and garlic bread.
Lembo's has a comfortable, old-school dining room that feels made for birthday dinners and team celebrations. The pizza leans traditional—think sturdy crust, plenty of toppings, and that unmistakable baked-in-the-deck-oven flavor. For Pigeon Creek families looking to make pizza part of a larger sit-down meal, this is an easy, reliable choice.