01
Best overall pick
3 Joe's Pizzeria & Trattoria
Downtown Piqua Near The Town Square • Sit-Down Italian Trattoria And Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Dine-In
A cozy downtown spot where you can linger over brick-oven pies and classic Italian comfort food.
3 Joe's feels like the place you bring family or out-of-town guests when you want to show off Piqua’s more polished side. The menu leans well beyond pizza, but their pies stand out thanks to a flavorful crust and generous toppings. It’s a reliable choice when you want a proper sit-down meal instead of a quick box to go.
02
Best value for big groups
East of Chicago Pizza
Neighborhood Location On Piqua’S South Side • Carryout And Delivery Pan-Pizza Joint • Great For Feeding A Crowd
Thick, bready crust and big combo deals make this a go-to when you’re ordering for a hungry group.
East of Chicago leans into hearty pan and specialty pizzas that can easily feed a family or a roomful of friends. The value combos and frequent specials mean you can load up on pizza, sides, and drinks without blowing the budget. It’s the kind of place locals call first for parties, game nights, and last-minute gatherings.
03
Best for families
Pizza Hut
Covington Avenue Retail Strip • Family-Friendly Dine-In And Carryout Chain • Kid-Pleasing Classic
A familiar sit-down Pizza Hut with pan pies, wings, and plenty of kid-friendly options right on Covington Avenue.
This Pizza Hut delivers exactly what many families want: shareable pans of pizza, breadsticks, and wings in a straightforward, relaxed setting. The menu is predictable in a good way, with crowd-pleasers like stuffed crust and classic Supreme. If you’re juggling kids, errands, and weeknight schedules, it’s an easy stop off the main drag.
04
Fastest delivery pick
Domino's Pizza
North Sunset Drive Near Us-36 • Delivery-Focused Chain Pizzeria • Best For Quick, Customizable Delivery
Domino’s is the go-to for fast delivery and highly customizable pies, especially when you want dinner to just show up at the door.
From build-your-own pizzas to specialty recipes, Domino’s makes it simple to fine-tune your order online and track it all the way to your porch. The location by North Sunset Drive is geared for efficiency, with quick turnaround on both carryout and delivery. It’s an easy pick for late work nights or spontaneous pizza cravings.
05
Best late-night carryout
Papa Johns Pizza
North Main Street Corridor • Takeout-Focused National Chain • Late-Night Carryout Option
A reliable stop for saucy, topping-loaded pizzas and signature garlic dip, especially when it’s getting late.
Papa Johns on North Main focuses on quick takeout and delivery, turning out consistently sauced, cheese-heavy pies with that familiar garlic-butter aroma. The menu skews toward specialty combinations and bundled deals that make ordering for a group straightforward. When other kitchens are closing and you still want a fresh, hot pizza, this is a solid bet.