01
Best overall pick
Crowtown Pizza
Coshocton • Small-Town Pizzeria And Pub • Local Favorite
Crowtown Pizza is the cozy Coshocton standby for generous pies, cold drinks, and an easygoing local crowd.
Expect hearty, well-topped pizzas that lean classic rather than trendy, along with wings and other game-day staples. It is an easy choice when you want a sit-down spot that still feels casual, especially if you are meeting friends from around the county. From Plainfield, it makes a straightforward trip into town for a Friday night pizza run.
02
Best small-town classic
Papa's Pizza
West Lafayette • Family-Run Carryout Shop • Best For Families
Papa's Pizza in West Lafayette is the definition of a small-town pie shop, with friendly service and crowd-pleasing pizzas built for sharing.
The crust is soft and slightly chewy, piled high with toppings and plenty of cheese, making it a hit with kids and picky eaters. Locals rely on it for family dinners, team parties, and casual nights in when nobody feels like cooking. Call ahead, grab your boxes, and you can be back in Plainfield before the pizza has time to cool.
03
Best build-your-own
East of Chicago Pizza
Newcomerstown • Casual Buffet-Style Chain • Best For Big Groups
East of Chicago in Newcomerstown offers customizable pizzas and a relaxed dining room that works well for teams, youth groups, and big families.
You can go thin, thick, or their signature pan-style crust and load it up with classic toppings or try one of their specialty combos. On busy nights the buffet-style setup and steady flow of fresh pies make it easy to keep everyone fed without overthinking the order. It is a handy option if you are already in Newcomerstown for errands or a game and want to sit down together afterward.
04
Fastest delivery
Domino's Pizza
Coshocton • National Delivery Chain • Best For Late Nights
Domino's in Coshocton is the go-to when you want a hot pizza delivered quickly with all the familiar chain options.
The menu is exactly what you expect: build-your-own pizzas, stuffed crust options, chicken, breads, and desserts, all geared toward quick delivery or pickup. The app and order tracker make it easy to time a stop on your way back through town, or to have a driver meet you at home on a long day. For Plainfield residents, it is one of the most reliable ways to get pizza without leaving the house.
05
Best sit-down chain
Pizza Hut
Coshocton • Casual Dine-In Chain • Best For Groups And Kids
The Coshocton Pizza Hut is a familiar choice for pan pizza, breadsticks, and a comfortable booth where everyone can spread out.
It is an easy place to bring a mixed group, with pizzas, pastas, and kids’ favorites all in one spot, plus the option to linger over a pitcher of soda. The classic pan crust and stuffed-crust pies are a hit after youth games or shopping runs in Coshocton. If you prefer to eat in rather than cart boxes back to Plainfield, this is a simple, reliable pick.