01
Classic local institution
Adornetto's Selected Italian
Maple Avenue North Of Zanesville • Old-School Italian Pizzeria • Best Overall Pick
Beloved, house-made pies and red-sauce comfort in a lively, old-school dining room.
Locals have been coming to Adornetto's for generations, and it remains the go-to when someone suggests real Zanesville pizza. From Pleasant Grove, it's a quick hop down Maple Avenue for chewy, edge-to-edge pies loaded with toppings and classic baked pasta. Expect a wait at peak times, but the generous portions and hometown feel make it worth planning around.
02
Best for families and groups
Pizza Cottage
North Zanesville Retail Corridor • Family-Friendly Regional Pizzeria • Best For Families
Big, shareable pies, friendly service, and a casual dining room that works well for groups.
Pizza Cottage brings a polished but relaxed chain vibe, with plenty of seating and a menu that keeps kids and picky eaters happy. Their pizzas lean cheesy and indulgent, with crowd-pleasers like loaded meat combos and veggie specials. It's an easy choice when you have a mixed group coming from around Pleasant Grove and north Zanesville.
03
Crispy thin-crust specialist
Donatos Pizza
East Zanesville • Thin-Crust Takeout And Delivery Shop • Game-Night Takeout Pick
Signature edge-to-edge toppings on a crisp, square-cut crust that's built for sharing.
If you like your crust cracker-thin and your toppings packed all the way to the edge, Donatos is the reliable answer. This location is dialed in for carryout and delivery, making it ideal for game nights or quick dinners back in Pleasant Grove. The pepperoni and serious cheese coverage are the move if you are ordering for a crowd.
04
Reliable weeknight choice
Marco's Pizza
South Zanesville • Neighborhood Delivery And Carryout Chain • Weeknight Delivery Staple
Soft, chewy crust pies with customizable toppings and solid value-focused deals.
Marco's hits the sweet spot between quality and convenience, especially when you want something better than basic national chains. The dough has a little more chew, and the sauce leans savory, which works well on their build-your-own and specialty pizzas. From Pleasant Grove, it's a straightforward drive, and online deals make it easy to feed a household without spending much.
05
Best for craft beer and pizza
Weasel Boy Brewing Company
Riverside, Near Downtown Zanesville • Brewpub With Artisan Pizzas • Relaxed Night-Out Pick
House-brewed beer paired with hand-crafted pizzas in a laid-back, music-friendly taproom.
Weasel Boy is known first for its craft beer, but the pizza program is a pleasant surprise and a draw on its own. Thin, bubbly crusts and creative topping combinations make it a fun alternative to strictly traditional shops. Grab a pie, sample a flight, and enjoy the live music or river views before heading back toward Pleasant Grove.