01
Best overall pick
Old Scratch Pizza
West Main Street In Troy • Lively Craft Pizza And Beer Hall • Destination For Wood-Fired Pies
A short hop from Pleasant Hill, Old Scratch turns out chewy, wood-fired pies with creative toppings in a buzzy, communal setting.
This is the spot locals name first when you ask where to grab great pizza near Pleasant Hill. The crust has just the right char, and the menu ranges from classic margherita to inventive specials piled with house-made ingredients. Long shared tables, a deep craft beer list, and quick counter service make it an easy choice for everything from weeknights to casual gatherings.
02
Best downtown sit-down
La Piazza
Downtown Troy Historic Square • Upscale Italian Restaurant With Brick-Oven Pizza • Best For Date Night
La Piazza pairs crisp, brick-oven pizzas with a classic Italian dining room right on Troy’s postcard-perfect square.
When you want pizza but also want to linger over dinner, La Piazza is the move. Their pies lean Italian, with simple toppings, good olive oil, and a nicely blistered crust that holds up under the cheese. It’s an easy spot to turn a quick pizza craving into a relaxed evening out with a glass of wine and a stroll around the square afterward.
03
Dayton-style classic
Marion's Piazza
Retail Corridor Near I-75 In Troy • Large Family-Friendly Pizzeria • Great For Big Groups
Marion’s serves ultra-thin, edge-to-edge pizzas on giant pans, tailor-made for teams, families, and after-game gatherings.
This Dayton-area institution brings its signature square-cut, topping-loaded pies to the Troy area, making it a popular meet-up spot for Miami County families. You order at the counter, grab a big table, and watch sheet pans of pizza land in the middle like centerpieces. It’s casual, loud in a good way, and ideal when you’re feeding a crowd from Pleasant Hill without breaking the bank.
04
Carryout favorite
Cassano's Pizza King
West Main Street Strip In Troy • Classic Regional Thin-Crust Chain • Best For Easy Pickup
Cassano’s is the go-to thin-crust carryout stop, with that nostalgic Dayton-style flavor many locals grew up on.
If you’re driving back toward Pleasant Hill and want something you can grab fast on the way, Cassano’s fits the bill. The crust is crackery and crisp, the toppings are chopped fine and spread all the way to the edge, and the sauce has that familiar sweet-savory profile. Call ahead, swing through for pickup, and you’re home with hot pizza in minutes.
05
Delivery standby
Domino's Pizza
Commercial Corridor In Troy • National Delivery And Carryout Chain • Late-Night And Last-Minute Option
Domino’s is the reliable choice when you want customizable pizza delivered out toward Pleasant Hill without overthinking it.
While it’s not a mom-and-pop shop, this Domino’s stays busy with Miami County families who rely on its fast delivery and consistent pies. The online ordering and tracking make it easy to time a pickup on your way back through Troy or have dinner show up at the door after a long day. With multiple crusts, sauces, and sides, everyone in the house can dial in their own favorite combination.