01
Small-town classic
Papa's Pizza Palace
Central Blanchester • Small-Town Family Pizzeria • Local Standby
A longtime Blanchester favorite turning out hearty pies in a friendly, no-rush setting.
If you ask around Pleasant Plain for an easy pizza night recommendation, Papa's in Blanchester comes up quickly. The crust is on the thicker side, toppings are generous, and the whole place feels built for Little League teams and families after a busy day. It’s the sort of spot where regulars have a go-to order and the staff tends to remember it.
02
Best for families
LaRosa's Pizzeria Goshen
Goshen Village Center • Cincinnati-Style Family Chain • Family Crowd-Pleaser
A reliable choice for Cincinnati-style pizza, big menus, and kids who want options beyond just cheese.
The Goshen LaRosa's is a go-to when you’ve got a mixed crowd and need something easy that still feels like a night out. The crust is thinner, the sauce leans a little sweet, and the menu stretches from pizza and calzones to pastas and wings. It’s close enough to Pleasant Plain for weeknight carryout but comfortable for a sit-down meal after games or school events.
03
Loaded-topping favorite
Grammas Pizza of Goshen
Along Sr-28 In Goshen • Old-School Takeout Joint • Best For Big Appetites
Thick, cheesy pies piled high with toppings, built for sharing with a hungry crew.
Grammas is the place you call when you want seriously substantial pizza without overthinking it. The crust runs thicker and airy, the cheese is generous, and classic toppings like pepperoni, sausage, and banana peppers come piled on. It’s a straight-shooting carryout spot that hits the mark when you’re feeding a crowd back in Pleasant Plain.
04
Neighborhood pick
Loveland Pizza Co.
Loveland Bike-Trail Area • Casual Neighborhood Spot • Best Post-Trail Slice
A laid-back pizza stop near the Loveland Bike Trail with creative pies and cold drinks.
For Pleasant Plain residents who regularly head toward the Little Miami trail, Loveland Pizza Co. is an easy add-on to the outing. The menu mixes classic toppings with more playful combinations, and the crust strikes a good balance between chewy and crisp. It’s a relaxed, local-feeling place where you can refuel after a ride or linger over a shared pie with friends.
05
Destination pick
Two Cities Pizza Co.
Historic Downtown Mason • Craft Pizzeria With New York And Chicago Styles • Worth The Drive
A polished Mason pizzeria known for standout New York slices and deep-dish pies in a lively, city-inspired space.
When you’re up for a longer drive in exchange for memorable pizza, Two Cities in Mason is the place to aim the car. The menu focuses on New York–style thin crust and Chicago-style deep dish, both done with attention to detail, from the dough to the sauce. It’s a popular date-night and special-occasion pick for Pleasant Plain locals who want something a step up from their usual carryout.