01
Best overall pick
Dewey's Pizza - Clifton
Clifton Near Uc • Creative Sit-Down Pizzeria • Best For Families
Inventive specialty pies, a bustling dining room, and an easy drive from Pleasant Run make Dewey's in Clifton a reliable go-to for pizza night.[4][5]
Dewey's Pizza in Clifton regularly shows up on lists of Cincinnati's top pizzerias thanks to its chewy, blistered crusts and creative topping combos.[4][5] The open-kitchen setup keeps kids entertained while adults work through a solid tap list and shareable salads before the main event.[4] From Pleasant Run, it's a straightforward drive down toward the university district for a sit-down pizza night that still feels distinctly Cincinnati.
02
Closest classic spot
Italianette Pizza - North College Hill
North College Hill • Old-School Cincinnati Carryout • Classic Local Standby
A no-frills favorite in nearby North College Hill, Italianette turns out hefty, square-cut pies loaded with toppings the Cincinnati way.[3]
Italianette's North College Hill shop is a staple stop for locals, and its inclusion among Cincinnati's standout pizza parlors is well earned.[3] Expect buttery crust, plenty of cheese, and that classic square-cut presentation that makes it easy to feed a crowd without fuss. It’s an especially handy pick when you want a quick carryout run just a few minutes south of Pleasant Run.
03
Worth the drive north
Fratelli's Pizzeria
West Chester • Family-Run Neighborhood Pizzeria • Worth The Drive North
Fratelli's in West Chester brings a slightly more upscale touch to classic pies, still close enough to Pleasant Run for a casual weeknight outing.[3]
Listed among greater Cincinnati's top pizza parlors, Fratelli's draws fans from around the north suburbs with its generous pies and consistent bake.[3] Inside, it’s relaxed and friendly, with plenty of room for families or teams to stretch out after a game. If you like leftovers, the large pies here travel well back to Pleasant Run.
04
Best for big groups and game nights
Queen City Pizza
Westwood On Cincinnati's West Side • Late-Night Slice Shop • Best For Big Groups And Game Nights
A west-side institution, Queen City Pizza in Westwood is the spot for big, cheesy carryout pies on your way home from downtown or the West Side.[3]
Queen City Pizza earns its place on Cincinnati best-of lists with classic, no-nonsense pies and subs that hit the spot late at night or after a game.[3] This is a grab-and-go kind of place, where the focus stays firmly on well-baked crust, hearty toppings, and friendly counter service. From Pleasant Run, it makes a convenient stop when you’re already headed toward the West Side for a concert or a Reds game.
05
Best for oversized slices
Ramundo's Pizzeria - Mt. Lookout
Mt. Lookout On The East Side • New York-Style Slice Joint • Best For Oversized Slices
For giant New York-style slices and a lively neighborhood vibe, Ramundo's in Mt. Lookout is worth the cross-town drive.[3][4]
Ramundo's is celebrated for its oversized, foldable slices and late-night hours, landing it on lists of must-try Cincinnati pizza spots.[3][4] The Mt. Lookout location has a casual, slightly rowdy energy on weekends, which pairs perfectly with a hot slice and cold drink after a night out.[4] If your Pleasant Run crew doesn’t mind a longer drive for pizza, this is the pick when you want that classic East Side bar-and-slice experience.