01
Best overall pick
New London Pizza House
Downtown London • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A long-running London staple turning out hearty, crowd-pleasing pizzas with a true hometown feel.
New London Pizza House is the kind of place where the staff recognizes regulars and the pizza tastes like it has been made the same way for decades—in a good way. Expect a generous layer of cheese, well-seasoned sauce, and slightly thicker crust that holds up under toppings. For Plumwood residents heading into London, it is an easy first choice when you want something unfussy and reliably satisfying.
02
Best for hearty slices
Phat Daddy's Pizza
East First Street, London • Casual Carryout And Dine-In Shop • Best For Big Appetites
Loaded specialty pies and daily specials make this London spot a go-to when you want plenty of food for the money.
Phat Daddy's leans into big toppings and shareable pizzas, ideal for feeding a crew after a game or gathering. The menu leans beyond basics with lots of meat-heavy and deluxe combinations, plus bargain-friendly lunch and daily specials. From Plumwood, it is an easy run into town when you want to skip cooking and come home with a stack of hot boxes.
03
Best for families
Cappy's Pizza
Near The Madison County Fairgrounds, London • Family-Friendly Pizza Restaurant • Best For Families
A welcoming London mainstay with familiar pizzas, friendly service, and plenty of options for picky eaters.
Cappy's hits that sweet spot of being relaxed enough for kids but consistent enough that locals keep it in their regular rotation. Pizzas come with a slightly crisp edge and balanced toppings, and there are plenty of sides and non-pizza options to round out a family meal. If you are coming into London from Plumwood for errands or events at the fairgrounds, Cappy's is a convenient stop to cap off the day.
04
Old-school classic
Ronetti's Pizza
Lafayette Street, London • Traditional Pizza Parlor • Best For Classic Pies
A longtime London favorite known for its straightforward, well-executed pies and throwback vibe.
Ronetti's feels like the kind of pizza place every small town used to have, with simple toppings, familiar flavors, and a focus on doing the basics right. The crust lands in that middle ground between thin and thick, sturdy enough for loaded toppings but never doughy. For Plumwood locals in the mood for a no-nonsense, nostalgic pie, Ronetti's is worth the drive into town.
05
Best short drive from Plumwood
Ange's Pizza
West Jefferson • Neighborhood Pizza Chain Outpost • Best For Quick Takeout
A reliable West Jefferson shop with consistent pies, convenient takeout, and familiar Columbus-style flavors.
The West Jefferson location of Ange's Pizza gives Plumwood residents another solid option beyond London, especially if you are already headed east toward I-70. Expect square-cut, Columbus-style pizzas with a thinner crust and edge-to-edge toppings, plus wings and subs if you want to mix it up. It is a practical, go-to stop when you want something fast and familiar on the way home.