01
Best overall pick
JJ's Pizza
In The Village Of Plymouth • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Go-To Choice For Locals
Longtime Plymouth favorite turning out crowd-pleasing pies with plenty of toppings and small-town hospitality.
JJ's has been feeding Plymouth and the surrounding countryside for decades, and it shows in the easy rapport between the staff and regulars. The dough is made in-house, the crust lands in that sweet spot between soft and crisp, and the toppings are generous without feeling overdone. It’s the kind of place where a large pepperoni, a side of cheesy bread, and a couple of cold sodas can anchor a Friday night at home.
02
Best nearby carryout
Slice of Heaven
Shiloh, Northeast Of Plymouth • Cozy Village Pizza Shop • Best For Takeout From A Nearby Town
Small but busy shop in Shiloh known for bubbly cheese, well-seasoned sauce, and friendly, no-fuss service.
Just a short drive from Plymouth, Slice of Heaven in Shiloh is the kind of spot where the phone rings steadily and the ovens rarely get a rest. Pizzas come out with a nicely browned cheese cap and a sauce that leans savory with just a touch of sweetness. Call ahead, grab your order, and you’ll be back on the road to Plymouth before the car has time to cool down.
03
Worth-the-drive classic
Cameo Pizza
Norwalk, North Of Plymouth • Old-School Ohio Pizza Joint • Best For Game-Day Feasts
Regional favorite serving crisp-edged pies that feel tailor-made for sharing with a hungry crowd.
If you’re willing to drive up to Norwalk, Cameo Pizza rewards you with that classic Ohio tavern-style experience. Expect a thinner crust with a satisfying crunch at the edge, plenty of cheese, and topping combinations that have clearly been refined over years of Friday-night orders. It’s a smart pick when you’ve got a house full of people and want a stack of boxes that everyone will be happy to open.
04
Best old-school atmosphere
Leaning Tower of Pizza
Mansfield, West Side • Retro Italian-American Pizzeria • Sit-Down Night Out
Mansfield institution pairing nostalgic dining-room vibes with hearty, cheese-forward pies.
Leaning Tower of Pizza feels like stepping into a time capsule in the best possible way, with red-checkered energy and plenty of locals who have been coming for years. The pizzas are substantial, with a thicker, chewy crust and a heavy hand with the cheese that makes each slice feel indulgent. Plan to sit down, linger over a pie, and make an evening of it rather than rushing back to the car.
05
Best value pick
Two Cousin's Pizza & Subs
Central Mansfield • Casual Pizza And Sub Shop • Best For Big Appetites On A Budget
No-frills Mansfield spot turning out solid, generously sized pizzas and subs at wallet-friendly prices.
Two Cousin's is the kind of unfussy place that focuses on giving you a lot of food for your money without cutting corners where it counts. The crust leans soft and comforting, making it a good match for extra cheese and hearty toppings like sausage and mushrooms. It’s an easy answer when you’re feeding a family or a small group and want leftovers for tomorrow’s lunch.