Polk may be a quiet village, but you are only a short drive from some of Ashland County’s most reliable pizza. Head into nearby Ashland for old-school carryout shops, family-run favorites, and modern wood-fired pies that feel worth the trip. Whether you are grabbing a quick box for movie night or planning a casual dinner out, these five spots are where locals tend to point you first.
A decades-long Ashland favorite known for straightforward, craveable pies and generous toppings.
DorLo is the place longtime Ashland families mention first when you ask where they grew up getting pizza. The crust lands in that sweet spot between soft and sturdy, with a sauce that leans savory rather than sweet. It is an easy pick when you want a no-fuss, crowd-pleasing pie on your way back to Polk.
Charred, chewy-crust pies with creative toppings make this one of the most memorable stops near Polk.
Holy Pepperoni leans into New Haven–style pizza, with a thinner, slightly charred crust and bold flavor combinations you do not see everywhere in rural Ohio. The menu changes just enough to keep regulars interested, but you can always count on a properly blistered edge and balanced toppings. It is a smart choice when you are up for something more characterful than a standard chain pie.
Big, cheesy pies and hearty toppings make this a reliable option when you are ordering for a group.
Besta Fasta leans into generous portions and straightforward combinations, which is exactly what you want for team dinners, sleepovers, or last-minute parties. The crust is a bit thicker and built to hold plenty of cheese and toppings without getting soggy. For Polk residents who host a crowd often, this is the place that keeps everyone full without breaking the budget.
A friendly, family-focused pizzeria with comforting, classic pies and a welcoming, small-town feel.
Donna D's feels like the kind of place where staff remember regulars’ orders and kids get excited about pizza night. The pies lean classic—think pepperoni, sausage, and veggie combos—with a sauce that has just enough sweetness to please younger eaters. It is a natural pick for Polk families who want a relaxed, reliable stop after games or errands in Ashland.
Wood-fired crusts, seasonal toppings, and a downtown setting make this the most date-night-friendly option nearby.
Ohio Fire brings a more modern, artisan feel to the local pizza scene, with blistered crusts and thoughtfully assembled topping combinations. The pies arrive with a bit of char and chew, and the menu usually includes a few options that showcase local ingredients. It is an easy recommendation when someone from Polk wants pizza that feels a step up from takeout, without driving to a bigger city.