01
Best overall pick
Fox's Pizza Den
East Main Street Riverfront • Casual Family Pizzeria • Go-To For Groups
A hometown-feeling spot that does hearty pies, strombolis, and wedges well enough to please a whole table.
Fox’s feels like the dependable local hub where teams pile in after games and families split a couple of big pies. The crust is substantial without being heavy, and the menu runs deep with strombolis, wings, subs, and large sheet pizzas that are easy to share. It’s the place to call when you’re feeding a crowd and want more variety than just a basic pepperoni.
02
Fast delivery standby
Domino's Pizza
West Main Street Corridor • National Delivery Chain • Best For Quick Delivery
Reliable, fast, and customizable, this Domino’s is the workhorse for easy weeknight pizza in Pomeroy.
If you want something hot on the doorstep without much planning, Domino’s on West Main gets the job done. The menu leans into build-your-own pies, specialty pizzas, and extras like stuffed cheesy bread and pasta bowls, so everyone can tweak an order to taste. It’s especially handy for late practices or busy nights when cooking just isn’t happening.
03
Classic pan-pizza fix
Pizza Hut
West Main Near Central Pomeroy • Familiar Dine-In Chain • Best For Pan Pizza Lovers
Thick, buttery pan pizzas and nostalgic chain comfort make this a solid sit-down or carryout choice.
Pizza Hut in Pomeroy is where you go when you’re craving that old-school pan crust with crispy edges and plenty of cheese. Beyond the pies, there are wings, breadsticks, and pastas that work well for sharing at the table or taking home. It’s an easy pick when you want something familiar that everyone at the table already understands.
04
Grab-and-go option
Hot Stuff Pizza
Highway Stop Through Town • Convenience-Store Pizza Counter • Best For Road-Trip Stop
A quick-slice counter that’s ideal when you want something warm and cheesy without a full sit-down meal.
Hot Stuff Pizza is the kind of place you duck into while fueling up or passing through, and it fills that role well. Expect ready-made slices, basic pies, and other quick bites that are easy to eat in the car. It’s not your linger-over-dinner choice, but it’s surprisingly handy when you just need fast comfort food between errands or on a long drive.
05
Worth the short drive
Hometown Pizza
Mason, Wv Across The River • Small-Town Sit-Down Pizzeria • Best Small-Town Vibe
A cozy, just-over-the-bridge shop where the pizzas feel homemade and the pace is unhurried.
Only a short hop across the river in Mason, Hometown Pizza is a nice change of pace from the chains. The crust has that slightly rustic, hand-worked feel, with generous toppings and plenty of cheese. It’s a good call when you want to make pizza night feel like a small outing rather than just another takeout order.