01
Best overall pick
Marco's Pizza
East Perry Street Corridor • Carryout And Delivery Chain Pizzeria • Go-To For Quick Family Dinners
A reliable stop for classic, customizable pies when you want something hot, fast, and familiar near downtown Port Clinton.
Marco’s on East Perry is the workhorse of the local pizza lineup, turning out consistently good, crowd-pleasing pies with plenty of topping options. It’s an easy choice when you’re feeding a crew at a rental, hotel, or campsite and need delivery that actually arrives on time. Order a couple of large specialty pizzas and a side or two and you’re set for a no-fuss night in.
02
Classic local joint
Bell Mell Pizza
Fulton Street Neighborhood • Casual Pizza And Spirits Hangout • Best For Big Groups And Game Nights
A laid-back pizza-and-spirits spot where locals gather for hearty pies, cold drinks, and a friendly, old-school vibe.
Bell Mell feels like the kind of hometown pizza bar you stumble into once and then start planning return trips around. The pies are generously topped and built for sharing, and the cozy, no-frills dining room makes it easy to settle in for an extra round. It’s an especially good call if you want to watch a game, split a few pizzas, and get a real read on the local crowd.
03
Downtown bar-and-pizza combo
The Brick House
Downtown Port Clinton Waterfront • Brick-Walled Bar And Pizzeria • Top Pick For Drinks And A Slice Downtown
A lively brick-lined spot downtown serving solid pies alongside a full bar, live entertainment, and plenty of bustle.
Steps from the waterfront, The Brick House pairs pizza with a full lineup of drinks and regular live music, so it’s as much about the night out as the slice. The pizza leans hearty and shareable, ideal for splitting with friends between bands or after a walk along the lake. If you want a place where the energy is as big as the toppings, this is your downtown stop.
04
Island crowd pleaser
Cameo Pizza at Fast Eddie's
Catawba Island / Route 53 • Island Pizza Counter In A Locals' Bar • Favorite Stop After A Day On The Lake
A long-running regional favorite serving signature pies out of a lively bar that draws both Catawba regulars and visitors heading to the islands.
Cameo Pizza inside Fast Eddie’s has the feel of a Catawba institution, with crisp, flavorful pies that hit the spot after time on the water or a run to the ferry. The crust has enough snap to stand up to generous toppings, and the atmosphere is casual, chatty, and very local. It’s the kind of place where boaters, anglers, and weekenders end up side by side over a hot pizza and a cold drink.
05
Gourmet slice destination
Sloopy's Pizza
Lakefront Strip Near The Marinas • Award-Winning Gourmet Pie Shop • Must-Try For Creative Toppings
A nationally recognized local shop known for inventive specialty pizzas that go well beyond the usual pepperoni-and-cheese routine.
Sloopy’s has earned awards for its gourmet pies, and it shows in the way they layer flavors, from sauce and cheese blends to creative topping combos. The space feels approachable and family-friendly, but the menu reads like something you’d expect in a bigger city. If you only have time for one truly distinctive pizza in the Port Clinton area, make it here and lean into one of their signature creations.