01
Closest hometown slice
Creno's Pizza Newcomerstown
Downtown Newcomerstown • Small-Town Pizzeria With Classic Ohio-Style Pies • Closest To Port Washington
A regional favorite in nearby Newcomerstown, known for generously topped pizzas and a true small-town feel.
For many Port Washington residents, Creno's in Newcomerstown is the go-to spot when they want pizza without driving all the way to the bigger cities. The crust is classic Ohio pizzeria style—sturdy but not too thick—with plenty of toppings and a sauce that leans slightly sweet. It is an easy pick when you want a local-feeling shop that still runs like a well-practiced chain.
02
Family night standby
Pizza Hut New Philadelphia
West New Philadelphia Commercial Strip • Family-Friendly Chain Restaurant • Best For Families
A familiar sit-down Pizza Hut where families from around Tuscarawas County head for pan pizza, wings, and a relaxed booth.
If you are making a grocery or shopping run into New Philadelphia, this Pizza Hut is an easy place to park the family for dinner. The menu sticks to the classics—pan pizzas, stuffed crust, wings, and pasta—so everyone can find something. It is especially handy when you want a predictable, kid-friendly stop after a busy day of errands.
03
Game-night delivery pick
Domino's Pizza New Philadelphia
New Philadelphia Near Downtown • Delivery-Focused Chain Shop • Fastest Delivery Option
Domino's in New Philadelphia is the reliable choice for quick, customizable pizzas when you would rather stay in.
This Domino's is popular with households that plan their pizza around kickoff, tipoff, or movie night. Online ordering makes it easy to build your own pie, track your order, and add extras like Parmesan bites or wings. For Port Washington folks willing to meet delivery partway or pick up in town, it is one of the faster, more flexible options.
04
Budget-friendly carryout
Little Caesars Pizza New Philadelphia
New Philadelphia Big-Box Corridor • Grab-And-Go Carryout Counter • Best Value Deals
Little Caesars in New Philadelphia is all about quick, inexpensive pies that are easy to grab on the way home.
When price matters more than variety, this Little Caesars is hard to beat. Hot-N-Ready pizzas and Crazy Bread make it a fast stop if you are already in New Philadelphia for shopping. It is a practical choice for feeding a carload of kids or covering a casual get-together without much planning.
05
Topping-loaded chain option
Papa John's Pizza New Philadelphia
North New Philadelphia Residential Edge • Carryout And Delivery Chain Pizzeria • Most Topping Choices
Papa John's in New Philadelphia leans into loaded specialty pizzas and custom builds with plenty of sauces and extras.
This location is popular with people who like lots of toppings and dipping sauces, from garlic Parmesan crusts to spicy sides. It is a go-to for larger orders thanks to frequent deals on multiple pizzas and sides. If you are coordinating a group meal for friends or family driving in from around Port Washington, it is a straightforward, crowd-pleasing pick.