01
Classic red-sauce institution
Regina's Pizza
East Avenue Near Barberton • Old-School Italian Pizzeria • Local Institution
Long-running, family-owned spot famous for cheese-heavy pies, sweet red sauce, and generous portions.
If you ask longtime Portage Lakes boaters where they’ve been ordering from for decades, Regina’s comes up fast. The crust has that slightly chewy, bakery-style bite, the sauce leans sweet, and the toppings are loaded on with a heavy hand. It’s the kind of place where a large pepperoni and a tray of garlic bread can easily feed a hungry crew after a day on the lake.
02
Weeknight takeout staple
Teresa's Pizza
Manchester Road Corridor • Neighborhood Carryout Shop • Best For Quick Takeout
Square-cut pies, crispy edges, and efficient service make this a go-to for fast, reliable pizza near the lakes.
Teresa’s is the classic call when you’re wrapping up a busy weekday and want hot pizza on the table without fuss. The crust is sturdy enough to hold plenty of toppings, the sauce is well-seasoned, and their menu covers everything from basic cheese to meat-loaded specials, plus subs and wings. Order ahead, swing by on Manchester Road, and you’re back home or at the dock in minutes.
03
Family dinner favorite
DeCheco's Pizzeria
Downtown Barberton • Family-Friendly Italian Restaurant • Best For Families
Comfort-food pizzas and red-sauce classics served in a laid-back dining room that works for kids, grandparents, and everyone in between.
DeCheco’s is a Barberton standby that many Portage Lakes families treat as their go-to sit-down pizza night. Pies come out with plenty of cheese and a soft, bready crust, and the menu stretches into pasta, salads, and fried appetizers so everyone can find something. It’s the kind of place where you can linger over a pitcher of soda or beer while sharing a couple of large pizzas at a big table.
04
Worth-the-drive legend
Guiseppe's Pizza
North Akron • Thin-Crust Pizzeria • Worth-The-Drive Favorite
Beloved Akron shop known for crisp, thin crust and pies packed edge-to-edge with toppings.
Guiseppe’s sits a little farther from Portage Lakes, but many locals happily make the drive when they want what they consider some of the best pizza in the Akron area. The crust bakes up thin and crunchy, with toppings and cheese pushed all the way to the rim so every bite is loaded. Call ahead, grab a couple of larges, and you’ll understand why it has such a loyal following across town.
05
Craft pizza & beer night
Dewey's Pizza
Fairlawn / West Akron • Modern Craft Pizza Spot • Best For Creative Toppings
Bright, bustling pizzeria with an open kitchen, standout specialty pies, and a solid beer list.
When you’re in the mood to trade classic pepperoni for roasted veggies, specialty meats, or bold sauces, Dewey’s is an easy choice. The crust is light and chewy with a bit of char, and you can split the pie half-and-half to try multiple combinations on one visit. It’s a great pick for meeting friends or grabbing dinner after a shopping run, with plenty of energy and a menu that rewards trying something new.