01
Best overall pick
Rubi's Pizza & Grill
Sunset Boulevard, Steubenville • Family-Friendly Pizza And Grill • Local Favorite For Variety
A versatile spot where you can pair crispy pies with wings, burgers, and a laid-back crowd.
Rubi’s is the kind of place you head to when not everyone at the table wants the same thing, but everyone agrees pizza has to be involved. The pies are sturdy, generously topped, and built to share, with plenty of pasta, burgers, and appetizers to round out the table. It’s an easy, no-fuss choice when you’re driving in from Pottery Addition and want dinner and a beer under one roof.
02
Classic Ohio Valley square-cut
DiCarlo's Pizza Downtown
Downtown Steubenville • Classic Ohio Valley-Style Pizzeria • Iconic Local Staple
Counter-service square slices with that trademark Ohio Valley combo of hot crust and cool toppings.
If you want to taste the style of pizza locals grew up on, the downtown DiCarlo’s is the reference point. Expect baking-hot crust and sauce, then cheese and toppings added after the pie comes out of the oven for a distinctly local texture and flavor. Grab a box of squares to go and you can be back in Pottery Addition before the cheese fully settles.
03
Old-school neighborhood stop
Bruno's Pizza
North End Steubenville • Carryout-Focused Neighborhood Pizzeria • Best For Quick Takeout
A straightforward shop turning out hearty, cheese-heavy pies and subs with no frills attached.
Bruno’s feels like the classic neighborhood joint where the focus is simply on feeding people well. The pizzas lean generous—plenty of cheese, solid crust, and a satisfying amount of toppings—making them ideal for low-key nights at home. Call ahead, swing through from Pottery Addition, and you’ll be back at the table with dinner before anyone can ask what’s taking so long.
04
Reliable delivery chain
Vocelli Pizza
Sunset Boulevard Corridor • Delivery-Focused Chain Pizzeria • Fast Delivery Option
A go-to when you want consistent, customizable pizzas delivered with plenty of sides to pad out the order.
Vocelli is the dependable choice when cooking is off the table and you want the order handled in a couple of clicks. The menu runs from classic pepperoni and veggie pies to specialty combinations, along with wings, breadsticks, and salads. It’s especially handy for Pottery Addition households on busy weeknights when delivery speed and predictability matter as much as the toppings.
05
Beloved neighborhood classic
Giannamore's Pizza
Hollywood Plaza Area, Steubenville • Family-Run Italian Pizzeria • Best For Families
A long-running local favorite known for crowd-pleasing pies, Italian comfort dishes, and a family-first feel.
Giannamore’s has the easy warmth of a place that’s been feeding the same families for generations. The pizza is classic comfort food—well-sauced, nicely browned, and built for sharing alongside salads and pasta. It’s worth the short drive from Pottery Addition when you want a sit-down meal that feels relaxed but still special enough for a Friday night tradition.