01
Best overall pick
Elliot's Wood Fired Kitchen & Tap
Old Powell Village • Wood‑Fired Kitchen And Taproom • Destination Night Out
A lively spot where blistered wood‑fired pies share the spotlight with a strong craft beer list.
Elliot’s is where Powell residents head when they want pizza to feel like an evening out, not just a quick bite. The crust comes out leopard‑spotted from the oven, with toppings that range from classic margherita to more chef‑driven combinations. With a full bar, plenty of taps, and a warm dining room, it’s an easy choice for date night or meeting friends in the heart of town.
02
Classic family Italian
Iacono's Pizza and Restaurant
Near Downtown Powell • Family Italian Restaurant • Family Favorite
Old‑school pizza and red‑sauce comfort in a relaxed, kid‑friendly setting.
Iacono’s delivers the kind of pizza that feels instantly familiar—crispy, cheesy, and built for sharing around a big table. The menu leans into Italian‑American comfort, so you can pair your pie with pasta, garlic bread, and hearty appetizers. It’s especially popular with families after games and school events, thanks to generous portions and friendly service that never feels rushed.
03
Best for New York–style cravings
Brooklyn Pizza
Liberty Street Corridor • New York–Style Pizzeria • Casual Slice Night
Thin, foldable slices and straightforward toppings make this a go‑to for no‑nonsense pizza.
Brooklyn Pizza focuses on the basics: a good dough, balanced sauce, and plenty of cheese, baked to that slightly crisp, foldable New York texture. It’s the kind of place locals rely on for quick carryout, but there’s enough seating if you want to stay for a low‑key meal. Straightforward combos and friendly pricing make it an easy pick for busy weeknights or impromptu slice runs.
04
Best for carryout and delivery
Flyers Pizza & Subs
Presidential Parkway Retail Area • Classic Carryout Pizzeria • Local Delivery Staple
Reliable, generously topped pies and subs that anchor many Powell takeout routines.
Flyers is the move when you want a crowd‑pleasing pizza night without dirtying a single pan. The crust is sturdy and slightly chewy, built to handle lots of toppings, and the menu stretches from classic pepperoni to specialty pizzas and oven‑baked subs. With efficient service and consistent quality, it’s one of the safest bets for delivery or easy pickup in the Powell–Dublin pocket.
05
Best for lingering over a meal
Carlucci's Pizzeria
Sawmill Parkway Corridor • Neighborhood Italian Spot • Sit‑Down Comfort Pick
A cozy Italian restaurant where pizza shares the menu with pasta, stromboli, and other classics.
Carlucci’s feels like a neighborhood fixture, with warm service and a menu that lets everyone find a favorite. Pizzas come with a slightly thicker, satisfying crust and plenty of topping options, but you can easily mix in pasta, salads, or stromboli for the table. It’s a solid choice when you want a sit‑down meal near Powell that still keeps pizza front and center.