01
Best overall pick
Riverside Restaurant
Powhatan Riverfront • Riverfront Bar And Grill With Pizza • Local Hangout
A true Powhatan Point staple, known for hearty pies, wings, and river views in a casual small-town setting.
If you ask around Powhatan Point where to grab a pizza, Riverside is the name you will hear first. The crust is sturdy enough for heavy toppings, and the sauce leans crowd-pleasing rather than fancy. It is the kind of place where the staff remembers regulars, the game is on the TV, and a big sheet pizza can feed an entire ball team after practice.
02
Classic regional slice
DiCarlo's Pizza
Glen Dale Strip • Ohio Valley Square-Cut Pizzeria • Classic Regional Style
Beloved for its Ohio Valley style squares, with hot crust and sauce topped with a layer of cold cheese right out of the oven.
DiCarlo's in nearby Glen Dale is a pilgrimage spot for anyone curious about true Ohio Valley style pizza. Expect square slices with a crisp, airy crust, simple tomato sauce, and a snowfall of shredded cheese added after baking. It is an old-school, no-frills counter operation where you order a tray, grab a soda, and eat like the locals have for generations.
03
Best for sit-down Italian
Figaretti's Restaurant
Wheeling Hilltop • Old-School Italian Restaurant • Best For Big Family Meals
A longtime Wheeling favorite where you can pair crisp, cheesy pizzas with red-sauce classics in a cozy dining room.
Figaretti's is the spot when you want pizza to be part of a full Italian night out rather than just a quick bite. The pizzas come with a slightly thicker, golden-brown crust and generous cheese, sharing the menu with house-made pasta and family recipes. It is a comfortable, multi-generation kind of place where Powhatan Point families drive in for birthdays, reunions, and Sunday dinners.
04
Chain comfort pick
Pizza Hut
Moundsville Commercial District • Family-Friendly National Chain • Best For Families On A Budget
A familiar option for Powhatan Point residents who want pan pizza, breadsticks, and an easy sit-down or carryout experience.
The Moundsville Pizza Hut is a go-to when you need something predictable that will keep everyone at the table happy. Classic pan pizzas, stuffed crust, and shareable sides make it ideal for youth teams, school nights, and quick family dinners. It is close enough to Powhatan Point for an easy pick-up run on the way home from errands or games across the river.
05
Best for delivery
Domino's Pizza
Wheeling East Side • Delivery-Focused Chain Shop • Late-Night Delivery Pick
Reliable, fast-turnaround pizza with lots of crust options and toppings, popular with locals who want delivery out toward Powhatan Point.
When cooking is off the table and you just want something hot at the door, the Wheeling Domino's is often the easiest call. The menu runs from hand-tossed and thin crusts to specialty pies, wings, and sandwiches, all geared around quick delivery. It is especially handy for late evenings or game nights when you would rather stay put in Powhatan Point and let dinner come to you.