01
Best overall pick
Romeo's Pizza
Village Center • Ohio-Style Chain Pizzeria • Best For Carryout
Thick, cheesy pies with a slightly sweet sauce make Romeo’s an easy first choice when you want classic, comforting takeout pizza.
Romeo’s leans into big flavors and generous toppings, so a single large pie can easily feed a couple of hungry people. The menu runs from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty pizzas, plus breadsticks and wings that travel well. It’s a straightforward, quick option when you want reliable pizza without a long wait.
02
Best wood-fired pies
Katimali's
State Street Corridor • Wood-Fired Italian Kitchen • Cozy Dine-In Pick
A locally owned spot where wood‑fired pizzas share the menu with Italian comfort dishes and family‑friendly portions.
Katimali’s feels more like a sit‑down neighborhood restaurant than a grab‑and‑go slice joint, with pizzas baked in a hot oven that gives the crust a bit of char and chew. You can keep it simple with a classic margherita or go for one of their specialty combinations alongside pasta, salads, or wings. It’s a good choice when you want to linger over dinner instead of rushing back to the car.
03
Classic local chain
Giovanni's Pizza
County Road 107 Strip • Classic Regional Pizza Parlor • Buffet And Group-Friendly
Giovanni’s serves up familiar regional pizza, subs, and a well‑liked buffet that suits families and teams after games.
Known around the Tri‑State, Giovanni’s in Proctorville leans into comfort food: thick, cheesy pies, garlic‑heavy breadsticks, and loaded subs. The buffet, when offered, makes it easy to keep everyone fed without arguing over toppings. It’s the kind of place locals pick for birthday parties, team outings, or a casual night when variety matters more than formality.
04
Reliable national favorite
Pizza Hut
County Road 107 Strip Near The River • National Pan-Pizza Chain • Game-Day And Kids' Favorite
This familiar Pizza Hut turns out the expected lineup of pan, hand‑tossed, and stuffed‑crust pies, plus wings and pastas for easy sharing.
If you know exactly how you like your chain pizza, this location delivers that same experience, from crispy‑edged pan crusts to customizable specialty pies. It’s especially handy for larger orders on busy nights, with online ordering and carryout making pickup straightforward. Kids tend to zero in on the breadsticks and stuffed crust, which keeps family pizza night low‑stress.
05
Worth the river crossing
Backyard Pizza & Raw Bar
Downtown Huntington, Wv • Wood-Fired Craft Pizzeria And Bar • Destination Outing
A short drive across the river rewards you with creative wood‑fired pizzas, a lively atmosphere, and plenty of craft‑minded touches.
Backyard Pizza is the kind of place you plan an evening around, with char‑blistered pies, inventive topping combinations, and a buzzy downtown setting. The menu changes enough to keep regulars interested, and there is usually a good selection of drinks to match. For Proctorville locals, it’s a go‑to when you want something a notch more adventurous than the standard hometown slice.