Radnor may be a small dot in Delaware County, but it sits within easy reach of some excellent pizza. From classic Ohio-style thin crust to blistered wood-fired pies and family-friendly dine-in joints, the nearby towns of Delaware and Sunbury deliver plenty of options. Use this guide to find the right slice whether you're heading out for a casual weeknight dinner or a post-game celebration.
Lively spot pairing creative pies with one of the better craft beer selections near Radnor.
Shorty's leans into bold toppings and shareable pizzas, from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty combos. The roomy, laid-back space makes it an easy choice for meeting friends after work or bringing a crew before a game. Expect a casual wait on busy nights, but the energetic vibe and rotating taps help pass the time.
Cozy, brick-oven spot known for charred crusts, quality toppings, and a slower, sit-down pace.
Amato's brings a more Italian feel to the local pizza scene, with a wood-fired oven that turns out blistered, chewy crusts. Toppings skew a little more upscale, with good fresh mozzarella, sausage, and seasonal specials. It is a solid pick when you want to make the short drive from Radnor for a relaxed dinner with a glass of wine or a date-night atmosphere.
Reliable, square-cut pies that feel straight out of a small-town Ohio pizza memory.
Fat Cat leans into comfort: generous cheese, plenty of toppings, and that familiar square-cut style many locals grew up with. The menu is broad enough to keep families happy, with subs and simple sides alongside the pizzas. It is the kind of spot you call for a Friday-night carryout when you want something filling and unfussy.
Hearty, hand-tossed pies and classic sides that travel well on the drive back toward Radnor.
Good Fella'z is built around convenience without skimping on portion size, with substantial pies, wings, and pastas geared to feed a crowd. The crust leans toward soft and chewy, with plenty of cheese and toppings piled on. It is a smart move when you want a straightforward pickup or delivery option after a long day.
Crisp, edge-to-edge thin crust pizzas that are consistent, quick, and easy to customize.
The Delaware Donatos location is a dependable go-to when you want something familiar and fast. Their trademark thin crust bakes up crisp, and the edge-to-edge toppings make even a basic pepperoni feel satisfying. Order ahead on busy evenings and you can swing by from Radnor, grab your boxes, and be back home before the cheese has time to cool.