01
Best overall pick
Heavenly Pizza
North Findlay • Classic Hometown Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A long-running local shop known for hand-tossed crust, generous toppings, and warm, small-town service.
Heavenly Pizza is the kind of place Rawson locals happily drive to when they want a familiar, reliably good pie. The crust has just enough chew, the sauce leans savory, and the toppings are piled on with a heavy hand. With subs, sides, and easy pickup options, it works as well for a busy weeknight as it does for a relaxed Friday dinner.
02
Flavor-packed carryout
Dougie's Pizza Co.
East Findlay • Takeout-Focused Pizza Shop • Best For Carryout And Delivery
Boldly topped pies, fair prices, and quick service make Dougie's a go-to when you want pizza on the table fast.
Dougie's leans into big flavor and convenience, with specialty pizzas that stack on meats, veggies, and cheese in crowd-pleasing combinations. The crust lands in that sweet spot between soft and crisp, sturdy enough to handle serious toppings. It is a smart pick when you are feeding a group back in Rawson and want your order hot, simple, and satisfying.
03
Game-day gathering spot
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
West Findlay Near I-75 • Lively Pizza-And-Wings Grill • Best For Groups And Sports
Big screens, a broad menu, and shareable pizzas make Beer Barrel a natural choice for game nights and family outings.
Beer Barrel combines hearty pizza with the feel of a full-service grill, so everyone at the table can find something they like. You can go classic with pepperoni and extra cheese or mix it up with specialty combinations and a side of wings. It is especially handy if you are meeting friends coming off the interstate and want an easy, relaxed spot to linger.
04
Old-school classic
Jac & Do's Pizza
Central Findlay • Retro Pizza Parlor • Best For Classic Pies
A no-frills favorite turning out crispy-edged, cheese-forward pizzas that taste like small-town Ohio nostalgia.
Jac & Do's has the lived-in, local feel of a spot that has been serving the community for decades. The pizzas lean classic Midwest: a thin-to-medium crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and plenty of cheese that browns nicely in the oven. It is the place you pick when you want a straightforward, familiar pie rather than something fussy or experimental.
05
Hearty campus staple
Campus Pollyeyes
Near The University Of Findlay • College-Town Pizza And Stuffed Breadsticks Joint • Best For Big Appetites
Known for hefty pizzas and famous stuffed breadsticks, this is the indulgent choice when you are really hungry.
Campus Pollyeyes draws students, families, and road-trippers with its generously topped pies and over-the-top stuffed breadsticks. The portions are substantial, and the menu invites you to customize with sauces and toppings until you land on your ideal combination. If you are heading in from Rawson and want one stop that will truly fill everyone up, this is a strong bet.