01
Best overall pick
Benny's Pizza Pub & Patio
Marysville – Northwest Side Near Us-33 • Lively Pizza Pub With Big Patio • Best For Groups And Live Music
Big, crowd-pleasing pies served alongside wings, cold beer, and one of the most popular patios in the Marysville area.
If you ask around Raymond or Marysville for a go-to pizza night spot, Benny's name comes up fast. The crust is sturdy enough for generous toppings, the sauce leans zesty, and specialty pies easily feed a table. In warmer weather, the sprawling patio with live music and plenty of seating makes it an easy choice for groups who want more than just a quick slice.
02
Family-friendly favorite
Flyers Pizza & Subs
Marysville – East Fifth Street Corridor • Casual Neighborhood Pizzeria • Best For Families
Square-cut pizzas, kid-friendly booths, and a broad menu of subs and wings make Flyers a low-stress choice for family dinners.
Flyers hits the sweet spot between classic central Ohio pizza and a full family menu. The pizzas come cut in small squares, with a slightly chewy crust and toppings right to the edge, so everyone can grab a piece or two of their favorite combo. Add in subs, salads, and wings, and it works just as well for a post-game team meal as it does for an easy Friday night from Raymond.
03
Thin-crust standby
Donatos Pizza
Marysville – Near Scottslawn Road • Ohio-Style Thin-Crust Chain • Game-Day Go-To
Crisp, edge-to-edge thin crust pies with predictable quality and quick service, ideal when you’re feeding a hungry crowd.
Donatos has built its reputation on a cracker-thin crust and toppings that stretch from one edge of the pizza to the other. In practice, that means every bite has a good balance of cheese, sauce, and whatever you’ve piled on, from classic pepperoni to their loaded specialty pizzas. For Raymond residents hosting a game-day gathering, it’s an easy, reliable option that travels well and disappears fast from the box.
04
Carryout classic
Marco's Pizza
Marysville – Shopping Strip Near Kroger Marketplace • Carryout And Delivery Pizzeria • Easy Weeknight Option
Cheesy, sauce-forward pies with plenty of topping combos, built for quick carryout or delivery after a busy day.
Marco's leans into comfort-food pizza: a slightly thicker, soft crust, lots of cheese, and a tomato sauce with a little sweetness. Their Old World pepperoni and specialty options make it simple to order something more interesting than a basic one-topping without overthinking it. When you’re driving back toward Raymond and just want to grab a reliable pizza on the way home, this shop fits neatly into the routine.
05
Worth-the-drive destination
Six Hundred Downtown
Bellefontaine – Historic Downtown • Wood-Fired Artisan Pizzeria • Destination Date-Night Spot
Competition-level, wood-fired pies in a charming downtown space that turns pizza into the main event.
Six Hundred Downtown is the place you drive a little farther for when you want truly standout pizza. The dough is carefully fermented, stretched by hand, and baked in a blazing hot oven that leaves the crust leopard-spotted and slightly chewy. With creative topping combinations, a tight but thoughtful beer list, and the character of Bellefontaine’s historic main street outside, it makes for a relaxed date night or special treat well worth the miles from Raymond.