01
Best overall pick
Deano's Pizza
Oregon • Family-Run Neighborhood Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Old-school pies, generous toppings, and a friendly small-town feel make Deano's a go-to for many Reno Beach regulars.
If you ask around at the marinas or campgrounds, Deano's is one of the first names you will hear. The crust is sturdy enough to handle heavy toppings, and the sauce leans classic and crowd-pleasing rather than experimental. It is the kind of place that works just as well for a family dine-in night as it does for a couple of large carryout pizzas back at the cottage.
02
Best for variety
Vito's Pizza and Subs
Navarre Avenue Corridor • Casual Pizza And Sub Shop • Best For Groups
A big menu of pizzas, subs, wings, and sides makes Vito's an easy choice when everyone wants something different.
Vito's is popular with bigger groups because you can cover a lot of bases with one order. The pizzas come with a slightly thicker, chewy crust and plenty of cheese, while the subs and wings travel well for a short drive back toward the lake. It is especially handy if you are feeding a mix of kids and adults after a long day on the water.
03
Most reliable delivery
Marco's Pizza
Oregon • Carryout And Delivery Chain Pizzeria • Delivery Standout
Marco's is the dependable option when you want hot, consistent pizza delivered without overthinking the order.
Marco's leans into familiar flavors: a slightly seasoned crust, tangy sauce, and plenty of topping combos, including their popular specialty pies. The Oregon location is used to handling larger orders and late-week rushes, which makes it a solid backup plan on busy summer nights. It is the place you call when convenience and consistency matter more than trying something new.
04
Best quick grab-and-go
Little Caesars Pizza
Oregon • Fast-Service Takeout Pizza Shop • Budget-Friendly Pick
For a fast, inexpensive pizza run on the way back from town, Little Caesars is hard to beat.
The appeal here is simple: walk in, grab a hot-and-ready pie, and be back on the road in minutes. It is especially handy if you need to feed a crowd of hungry kids without a lot of advance planning. While it is not trying to be gourmet, the Oregon shop is efficient and consistent, which matters when you are juggling beach gear and a tight timeline.
05
Classic Toledo-style choice
Gino's Pizza & Spaghetti
East Toledo • Old-School Italian-American Pizzeria • Sit-Down Comfort Spot
A longtime Toledo-area name, Gino's offers thicker, hearty pizzas and red-sauce comfort dishes in an easygoing setting.
If you feel like making a slightly longer drive for a sit-down meal, Gino's brings a nostalgic, Italian-American vibe that is worth the trip. Their pizzas skew hearty, with plenty of cheese and a crust that can stand up to sausage, pepperoni, and extra toppings. Add in pasta, salads, and garlic bread, and it becomes a relaxed option for a full dinner out before heading back toward Reno Beach.