01
Best overall pick
Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery
E Main Street Corridor • Wood-Fired Pizzeria And Bakery • Craft-Focused Neighborhood Favorite
Artisan wood-fired pies with a small-batch bakery feel and a true local following.
Tyler’s feels like the kind of place built by people who really care about dough, with pizzas that come out of the oven nicely blistered and balanced rather than overloaded. Toppings lean thoughtful instead of gimmicky, and the crust has enough chew and char to stand on its own. The bakery side means you can walk out with something sweet for the next morning as well as dinner for tonight.
02
Classic institution
Vick's Gourmet Pizza
Olde Reynoldsburg • Old-School Pizza Pub • Old-School Local Favorite
A longtime Reynoldsburg staple known for tavern-style pies, cold drinks, and a loyal regular crowd.
Vick’s is one of those places where families have been ordering the same pie for years, and the staff often knows regulars by name. The pizza leans classic—think crispy edges, generous toppings, and shareable party-cut slices that work well with a pitcher at the table. It’s a comfortable, no-rush kind of spot when you want a familiar, satisfying pizza night without overthinking it.
03
Columbus-style standout
Massey's Pizza
East Broad Street • Columbus-Style Thin-Crust Pizzeria • Best For Sharing With A Crowd
Crisp, edge-to-edge topping pies cut into party squares, made for groups and game days.
Massey’s leans into the classic Columbus-style formula: thin, crisp crust, toppings spread right to the edge, and pizzas sliced into small squares that disappear quickly. It’s a strong choice when you’re feeding a larger group and want consistent, crowd-pleasing flavors. The menu runs deep with subs, wings, and salads, so it’s easy to round out a full spread for a game or get-together.
04
Family-friendly pick
Romeo's Pizza
Tussing Road Area • Casual Carryout And Delivery Shop • Family-Friendly Value Pick
Thick, cheesy pies and specialty combinations that work well for easy family dinners.
Romeo’s is the kind of place you call when you need a dependable pizza night without much planning. Crusts skew thicker and a bit softer, with a sauce that leans slightly sweet and plays well with classic toppings. Their specialty pies give you enough variety to keep regular orders from feeling repetitive, and the portions are generous for the price.
05
Best for deep-dish
Jet's Pizza
Mcnaughten Road Corridor • Detroit-Style And Deep-Dish Chain • Hearty Takeout And Delivery Option
Square, cheesy-edged Detroit-style pizzas with a substantial crust and plenty of topping coverage.
Jet’s is all about the crust, especially the thick, airy, pan-baked squares with caramelized cheese along the edges. It’s a heavier, comfort-food style of pizza that delivers when you’re hungry and not counting slices. Between customizable crust options and quick turnaround for carryout or delivery, it fits nicely into busy weeknights or casual hangouts at home.