01
Best overall pick
DiCarlo's Pizza - Wintersville
Wintersville • Classic Steubenville-Style Pizzeria • Iconic Local Favorite
A short drive from Richmond for legendary square-cut pizza with the signature drizzle of sauce and toppings over just-baked crust.
If you ask folks around Richmond where they’ll happily drive for a pie, DiCarlo’s in Wintersville comes up fast. This is the classic Steubenville-style experience: crisp, airy squares, a tangy red sauce, and cheese and pepperoni added after the crust comes out of the oven. It’s simple, nostalgic, and exactly the kind of pizza that keeps people loyal for decades.
02
Classic local icon
Giannamore's Pizza
Wintersville • Old-School Takeout Pizza Shop • Best For Carryout Nights
Beloved for its no-frills counter service, chewy crust, and saucy pies that travel well back to Richmond.
Giannamore’s leans into that old-school, neighborhood-pizza-shop feel, with a focus on consistent, satisfying pies. The crust has just enough chew to stand up to a generous layer of sauce and cheese, making it ideal for takeout. Call ahead, swing through Wintersville, and you’ll be back in Richmond with a hot box and the car smelling like garlic and oregano.
03
Sit-down favorite
Bruno's Pizza
Steubenville • Family Italian Pizza Restaurant • Best For Lingering Dinners
A comfortable Steubenville spot where Richmond locals head when they want pizza plus a full Italian dinner experience.
Bruno’s is the place to go when you’re not in a rush and want more than a quick slice. The pizzas come with a heartier crust and well-seasoned sauce, and the menu stretches into classic red-sauce pastas and appetizers. It’s a dependable pick for small celebrations, team outings, or any night when you’re willing to make the drive from Richmond for a sit-down meal.
04
Reliable chain option
Domino's Pizza - Wintersville
Wintersville • National Delivery Chain • Best For Late-Night And Easy Delivery
Fast, customizable pies with online ordering that makes getting pizza to a Richmond address straightforward.
When convenience is the priority, the Wintersville Domino’s is the workhorse for many Richmond households. The menu covers all the chain favorites—hand-tossed, thin crust, and specialty pies—plus wings, bread twists, and desserts. It’s not trying to be a mom-and-pop joint, but for game nights and last-minute cravings, it reliably gets hot pizza to your door without much fuss.
05
Family-friendly classic
Pizza Hut - Wintersville
Wintersville • Casual Dine-In And Carryout Chain • Best For Kids And Big Groups
Familiar pan and stuffed-crust pizzas that make it an easy choice for family outings coming in from Richmond.
The Wintersville Pizza Hut is the kind of place where you can roll in with a car full of kids and know exactly what you’re getting. Thick, buttery pan crusts, plenty of cheese, and a lineup of sauces and toppings keep everyone at the table happy. Add in the option to dine in or grab carryout on the way back through to Richmond, and it becomes a dependable go-to for group plans.