01
Weeknight workhorse
Georgio's Oven Fresh Pizza Co.
Richmond Heights – Highland Rd • Busy Carryout And Delivery Shop • Best All-Around Delivery
A reliable Richmond Heights staple turning out crowd-pleasing pies, subs, and sides at fair prices.
Georgio's is the kind of place locals keep on speed dial for last-minute dinners and game-day spreads. The crust leans classic Cleveland carryout—sturdy, a little chewy, and built to hold plenty of toppings without getting soggy. Wings, JoJo potatoes, and big salads make it easy to feed a mixed crowd without overthinking the order.
02
Cleveland-style classic
Congin's Pizza
Euclid – East 185Th Corridor • Old-School Neighborhood Pizzeria • Classic East Side Takeout
Beloved for its square-cut pies, Congin's is a go-to for East Siders who like their pizza cheesy, saucy, and unapologetically old-school.
A short drive north from Richmond Heights, Congin's feels like stepping into a time capsule of Cleveland pizza culture. The pizzas come cut into small squares with a zesty sauce, generous cheese, and a crust that strikes a sweet spot between crisp and bready. Regulars swear by the sausage and pepperoni combo, plus a side of their garlic bread for the full experience.
03
Little Italy favorite
Corbo's Pasta & Pizza House
Cleveland – Little Italy • Italian Bakery And Pizza Counter • Worth-The-Drive Destination
Part pastry shop, part pizzeria, Corbo's is ideal when you want a slice and something sweet on a Little Italy stroll.
Corbo's draws Richmond Heights residents down to Little Italy for crisp-edged pies served alongside cannoli, cookies, and espresso. The pizza has a thinner, slightly blistered crust, plenty of cheese, and toppings that feel more Italian deli than generic chain. Grab a few slices to share, then finish with a box of pastries for the ride back up the hill.
04
Old-world charmer
Mama Santa's Ristorante & Pizzeria
Cleveland – Little Italy Side Street • Family-Run Red-Sauce Italian Restaurant • Best For A Lingering Sit-Down Meal
A cozy Little Italy institution where the pizza is as much a draw as the heaping plates of pasta.
Mama Santa's is a classic choice when you want to make pizza dinner feel like an outing instead of just takeout. The pies are straightforward—thin to medium crust, light char, and a well-seasoned sauce—best enjoyed hot out of the oven with a carafe of house wine. Expect a wait on weekends, but the old-school atmosphere and reliably good pizza make the trip from Richmond Heights worthwhile.
05
Neighborhood institution
Geraci's Restaurant
University Heights – Warrensville Center Rd • Classic Cleveland-Style Pizza Parlor • Family Night Favorite
An East Side standby turning out square-cut, cheese-laden pies that generations of locals have grown up on.
Just a short hop southwest of Richmond Heights, Geraci's delivers the kind of pizza that defines comfort food for many Clevelanders. The crust is thin but not cracker-like, with a slightly sweet sauce and a heavy blanket of browned cheese, all cut into easy-to-share squares. With roomy booths, personable servers, and a full menu of Italian standards, it’s an easy pick for family dinners and casual gatherings.