01
Best overall pick
Your Pizza Shop Richville
Richville • Classic Ohio-Style Carryout Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A Richville go-to for generously topped pies, crispy crust, and no-fuss takeout.
Sitting right in Richville, this branch of Your Pizza Shop is the kind of place where staff recognize regular orders and the pizza leans comfort over trendiness. The crust is sturdy enough to hold plenty of toppings, with sauce that is a touch sweet in true Stark County style. It is a reliable choice for Friday-night carryout or easy game-day feeding.
02
Stark County classic
Pizza Oven – South Cleveland Ave
South Canton • Old-School Takeout Pizza Joint • Best For Big Orders
Beloved for its square-cut pizzas, pepperoni rolls, and the kind of sauce locals grow up on.
Just a short drive north of Richville, the South Cleveland Ave Pizza Oven is a standby for Stark County families. Expect soft, slightly chewy crust, a generous layer of cheese, and classic toppings that work well for feeding a crowd. Add in pepperoni rolls and broasted chicken and you can cover a whole party with one pickup stop.
03
Loaded-topping specialist
Kraus' Pizza – Massillon Amherst Road
Massillon Amherst Road Corridor • Hearty, Topping-Heavy Pizzeria • Best For Hearty Eaters
A short hop from Richville, known for piles of toppings and thick, cheesy pies.
Kraus' on Amherst Road in Massillon is the place to go when you want a pizza that feels like a full meal. Their pizzas come loaded edge to edge, with a slightly thicker crust that can handle everything from extra cheese to all-meat combinations. It is a popular option for families driving over from Richville who want seriously filling slices.
04
Late-night favorite
Lindsey's Pizza
Near Downtown Canton • Casual Neighborhood Pizza Shop • Best For Night Owls
A Canton staple with big, cheesy pies and hours that work for late cravings.
Lindsey's draws a steady mix of locals, students, and service workers looking for solid pizza after typical dinner hours. The crust leans on the softer side, with a generous layer of cheese and classic toppings that hit the spot when you are hungry. It is close enough to Richville for a quick drive when everything closer has already closed.
05
Small-town standout
Pizza Oven – Navarre
Navarre • Small-Town Carryout Pizzeria • Best For River-Town Detour
A cozy Navarre outpost serving the same familiar Pizza Oven pies in a quieter setting.
If you are heading southwest from Richville, the Navarre Pizza Oven makes an easy detour for takeout before a drive along the river. The menu sticks to the brand's basics: square-cut pizzas, well-seasoned sauce, and straightforward toppings that please mixed groups. It is especially handy when you want that Stark County pizza taste without driving into busier parts of Canton.