01
Best overall pick
Gionino's Pizzeria
East Ohio Avenue, Rittman • Regional Pizzeria With Carryout And Delivery • Local Favorite For Big-Flavor Pies
Gionino’s is the go-to in Rittman for generously topped, old-school pies and crispy fried chicken on the side.
If you ask around town where to order pizza, Gionino’s name comes up fast. The crust is sturdy enough for heavy toppings, and the sauce leans savory with just enough sweetness to keep it balanced. Add a box of their fried chicken and jojo potatoes and you’ve got an easy crowd-pleaser for game night or a backyard get-together.
02
Best for families
Fox's Pizza Den
Historic Downtown Rittman • Casual Small-Town Pizza Shop • Best For Families And Groups
Fox’s Pizza Den turns out crowd-pleasing pies, strombolis, and hoagies in a relaxed Main Street setting.
Fox’s leans into that small-town, everyone-knows-you vibe, with friendly service and an easygoing pace that works well for families. The pizzas come with a soft, chewy crust and plenty of cheese, and the menu is broad enough that picky eaters can find something. Look for their larger party-size pizzas and combo deals if you’re feeding a group after a game or practice.
03
Best national chain option
Pizza Hut
North Main Street Corridor • Familiar Dine-In And Carryout Chain • Best For Classic Comfort Pizza
Rittman’s Pizza Hut delivers the chain’s signature pan and stuffed-crust pies with fast, predictable service.
When you want exactly what you expect from a big national name, this Pizza Hut is the reliable standby. The buttery pan crust, cheese-stuffed options, and lineup of wings and sides make it a straightforward choice for quick weeknight dinners. It’s especially handy when you need easy online ordering and consistent results for takeout or delivery.
04
Best for thick and cheesy
East of Chicago Pizza
In-Town Rittman Location • Carryout-Focused Pan-Pizza Chain • Best For Hearty Pan Pizza Cravings
East of Chicago is where to call when you’re in the mood for thick, doughy crusts loaded with cheese and toppings.
This spot leans into the brand’s signature pan and specialty pizzas, which come out substantial and filling. The crust is thicker and softer than most, making it a good match for heavy toppings, extra cheese, or stuffed options. It’s a smart pick for takeout when you want a hearty, comfort-food style pie rather than something light and crisp.
05
Worth-the-drive classic
Marie's Pizza & Chicken
Short Drive To Wadsworth • Old-School Pizzeria And Chicken Joint • Destination For Crispy Crust And Fried Chicken
About a ten-minute drive from Rittman, Marie’s is a long-running local favorite known for its crisp-edged pies and fried chicken dinners.
If you’re willing to hop over to Wadsworth, Marie’s feels like the kind of old-school neighborhood place people grow up with and never stop craving. The pizza leans toward a thinner, crispier crust with well-seasoned sauce and classic toppings done right, and the fried chicken is a draw all its own. Expect it to be busy on weekend evenings, so calling ahead for carryout is a good idea.