01
Best overall pick
Two Cities Pizza Co.
Mason Near Kings Island • Bustling Brewpub-Style Pizzeria With Ny And Chicago Pies • Destination-Worthy Night Out
Worth the extra drive from Roachester for standout New York and Chicago–style pies in a lively converted streetcar station setting.
Two Cities is the spot locals recommend when you ask where to go for a proper pizza night, not just a quick carryout. The menu splits between foldable New York slices and hefty Chicago deep dish, plus creative specialty combinations and a solid craft beer list. It works as well for a family meal after a day at Kings Island as it does for a casual date night away from the back roads around Roachester.
02
Classic regional choice
LaRosa's Pizzeria Lebanon
Lebanon • Family-Friendly Regional-Chain Pizzeria • Reliable Crowd-Pleaser
A go-to for Roachester families who want familiar Cincinnati-style pizza with plenty of topping options and easy dine-in or carryout.
LaRosa's in Lebanon brings the well-known Cincinnati-style crust and sweet-leaning sauce a short drive from Roachester. It is an easy choice when you have a mixed group, thanks to build-your-own pies, thick and thin crusts, pastas, and kid-friendly portions. Call ahead for carryout on busy evenings, or dine in if you are pairing pizza with a stroll around Lebanon’s shops.
03
Old-school local favorite
Angelo's Pizzeria
West Side Of Lebanon • No-Frills Neighborhood Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A straightforward, sauce-forward pie joint where crispy-edged pizzas and generous toppings keep Lebanon locals coming back.
Angelo's feels like the kind of independent shop every small town claims as its own, and it is a solid option if you want something a bit more homespun than the big chains. Expect thin-to-medium crust, plenty of cheese, and classic topping combos rather than trend-chasing specials. It is especially handy for Roachester residents cutting through Lebanon on OH-48 and looking for a dependable take-home pizza.
04
Best small-town stop
American Pie
Downtown Waynesville • Cozy Small-Town Pizzeria • Best After Antique Shopping
A friendly Main Street pizzeria where you can refuel on thick, cheesy slices after browsing Waynesville’s antique shops.
Located right in Waynesville’s walkable downtown, American Pie is an easy detour from Roachester, especially if you are already in town for antiquing or a festival. The pizzas lean comforting and hearty, with plenty of cheese and a crust sturdy enough to stand up to loaded toppings. Grab a whole pie for the family, or split a couple of specialty creations and linger over refills while people-watching on Main Street.
05
Convenient carryout pick
Marco's Pizza Lebanon
Lebanon Commercial Strip • Fast-Casual Carryout And Delivery Pizzeria • Best For Quick Pickup
A practical choice for Roachester-area residents who want consistent, customizable pies ready fast for pickup on the way home.
Marco's in Lebanon gives you a straightforward way to bring pizza back to Roachester without a long wait or sit-down stop. The dough has more chew than most big-box chains, and you can choose from a range of sauces, crust styles, and toppings to keep repeat orders from feeling stale. It is particularly useful on busy weeknights when you are cutting through Lebanon and just need hot, reliable pizza on the table with minimal fuss.