01
Classic sit-down pick
Lorenzo's Pizzeria
Downtown Oberlin • Sit-Down Italian Pizzeria • Classic Local Favorite
A longtime Oberlin staple known for generous pies, red-sauce comfort dishes, and friendly small-town service.
If you want a proper night out with pizza, Lorenzo's is the place most locals will suggest first. The crust has just enough chew, toppings are substantial without being overdone, and the menu stretches into pastas and sandwiches for mixed groups. It’s an easy choice when you’re coming into Oberlin from Rochester and want a relaxed meal right on the main drag.
02
College-town favorite
Cameo Pizza Oberlin
Near Tappan Square In Oberlin • Lively College-Town Pizza Joint • Best For Late-Night Slices
Crisp-edged pizzas, subs, and wings served in a casual spot that hums with Oberlin student energy most nights.
Cameo leans into the fun, with plenty of topping combos, shareable sides, and a casual scene that works well after a game or concert. The crust is on the thinner, crispier side, making it great for loaded specialty pies that don’t get soggy. It’s the kind of place where you grab a booth, catch up with friends, and work through a large pizza slice by slice.
03
Family standby
Pizza Hut Wellington
Wellington Village Center • Family-Friendly National Chain • Best For Families
A reliable stop for familiar pan pizzas, breadsticks, and kid-friendly combos right in the heart of Wellington.
When you need something everyone will agree on, the Wellington Pizza Hut is a straightforward pick. Families from outlying areas like Rochester appreciate the roomy seating, predictable menu, and deals that make feeding a crowd easier on the budget. It’s especially handy after youth sports or errands in town when cooking at home just isn’t in the cards.
04
Quick delivery choice
Domino's Pizza Wellington
North End Of Wellington • Carryout And Delivery Spot • Go-To Delivery Option
Fast, customizable pizzas and sides with late hours that make it an easy call-in option from the Rochester area.
For nights when you’d rather stay put, the Wellington Domino’s is often the quickest route to a hot pizza on the table. The online ordering and tracking make it easy to customize everything from crust style to sauce level, which regulars from nearby rural roads appreciate. It’s the practical, no-fuss answer for weeknights, study sessions, or unexpected guests.
05
Hearty buffet-style pick
East of Chicago Pizza New London
Main Street In New London • Buffet-Style Midwestern Chain • Best For Big Appetites
Thick, bready crusts and a rotating buffet of pizzas and sides make this a popular option for groups and teams.
East of Chicago in New London is a favorite when you’ve got a hungry crew and want plenty of variety. The pizza leans hearty, with a soft, substantial crust that works well for deep-dish and loaded topping combinations. Between the buffet setup and regular specials, it’s an easy group meet-up spot for folks coming from Rochester, New London, and the surrounding back roads.