01
Best overall pick
R Pizza Place
Downtown Columbiana • From-Scratch Family Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A cozy Main Street spot locals swear by for hand-tossed pies and friendly small-town service.
About 15 minutes northwest of Rogers, R Pizza Place is the classic small-town pizzeria built around homemade dough and sauce. Toppings are generous without getting heavy, and the crust strikes a nice balance between chewy and crisp. It is a strong choice when you want a relaxed sit-down meal that still feels quick and easy.
02
Heaviest hitter on toppings
Gionino's Pizzeria
West Side Of Columbiana • Busy Regional-Chain Pizzeria • Best For Big Appetites
Known for thick layers of cheese and toppings, this spot turns out hefty pies that easily feed a crew.
Gionino's in Columbiana is a popular call-ahead option when you are driving up from Rogers and need pizza for a crowd. The crust leans slightly thicker, built to hold serious amounts of cheese, pepperoni, and extras without falling apart. Add in their well-loved fried chicken and jojo potatoes and you have an easy game-day or family-night spread.
03
Best for a quick slice run
Pizza Joe's
Downtown East Palestine • Classic Small-Town Pizza Counter • Grab-And-Go Favorite
A straightforward counter-service shop that delivers dependable pies and subs just up the road from Rogers.
Head northeast from Rogers and Pizza Joe's in East Palestine makes an easy stop for carryout or a casual bite. The pies are classic Ohio style—moderate crust, lots of cheese, and a sauce with a little sweetness. It is the kind of place where you can grab a pepperoni pizza and a couple of subs and be back home before everything cools off.
04
Most flexible menu
East of Chicago Pizza
Along Route 45 In Lisbon • Casual Buffet-Style And Carryout Pizzeria • Best For Mixed Groups
A versatile Lisbon spot offering multiple crust styles, wings, and a rotating buffet on select days.
If your group can never agree on crust thickness, East of Chicago in Lisbon is a practical choice west of Rogers. You can mix and match pan, thin, and specialty crusts, then round things out with wings, breadsticks, or a quick buffet visit when it is running. It is especially handy for families or teams rolling in after games at the fairgrounds or nearby fields.
05
Best chain comfort pick
Marco's Pizza
Calcutta Near East Liverpool • Takeout-Focused Chain Pizzeria • Reliable Carryout Option
A familiar name turning out consistent, sauce-forward pies on the main commercial strip in Calcutta.
When you are farther south of Rogers toward Calcutta and East Liverpool, Marco's is a reliable stop for familiar, crowd-pleasing pizza. Expect a slightly chewy crust, a zesty red sauce, and plenty of specialty combinations if you want something beyond basic pepperoni. Order ahead, swing through for pickup, and you are back on the road with hot boxes in minutes.