01
Best overall pick
Pizza Hut
New Lexington • Sit-Down Chain Pizzeria • Reliable Crowd-Pleaser
A familiar dining room with consistently hot pan pizzas and easy big-group ordering.
For many Rose Farm families, the New Lexington Pizza Hut is the default choice when everyone wants something familiar and filling. The dining room is relaxed enough for kids and ball teams, but you can also call ahead for takeout on your way back from town. Go for the classic pan crust and shareable pastas when you have a mixed crowd to feed.
02
Best for quick carryout
Domino's Pizza
Crooksville • Fast-Delivery Chain • Best For Busy Weeknights
A go-to stop for fast, customizable pizzas when you need dinner on the table without a lot of planning.
The Crooksville Domino's is popular with commuters heading home toward Rose Farm after late shifts or practices. Online ordering and frequent deals make it easy to grab a couple of pizzas, bread twists, and wings without stretching the budget. It is more about speed and convenience than atmosphere, so plan to carry out or meet a driver at the end of the lane.
03
Best for sit-down dinners
Pizza Hut
Crooksville • Casual Family Restaurant • Best For Families
A classic small-town Pizza Hut where kids, grandparents, and everyone in between can linger over pizza and salad.
Crooksville’s Pizza Hut feels like the kind of place where teams come in still in their uniforms after a game. The salad bar, pitchers of soda, and big pan pizzas make it a low-stress choice when you have several people to feed and do not want to cook. It is an easy meet-in-the-middle option if your group is scattered between Rose Farm, Crooksville, and New Lexington.
04
Best bar-style pie
Philo Tavern
Philo • Neighborhood Tavern With Pizza • Laid-Back Evening Spot
A small-town tavern known for crispy, bar-style pizzas that pair well with a cold drink.
If you do not mind a short drive and a more adult atmosphere, Philo Tavern is where locals head for a thin, crispy pie and a beer. The menu leans tavern-classic, but the pizza is the standout, especially with plenty of toppings cut to the edge. It is a comfortable choice for a low-key night out with friends rather than a kids’ party stop.
05
Worth-the-drive favorite
Adornetto's Pizza
Zanesville • Old-School Italian Pizzeria • Destination Pick
A long-running Zanesville staple serving saucy, cheese-heavy pies in a throwback dining room.
When Rose Farm locals say they are “going to town” for pizza, Adornetto's in Zanesville is often the place they mean. The pies come loaded with a slightly sweet red sauce and plenty of cheese, and the booths and red-sauce Italian sides feel a step up from basic carryout. It is a bit of a drive, but many people treat it as a standing family tradition or a Friday payday splurge.