01
Best overall pick
Leaning Tower of Pizza
South Mansfield On Lexington Avenue • Old-School Dine-In Pizzeria • Classic Local Favorite
A Mansfield institution with chewy crust, generous cheese, and a lived-in dining room locals know by heart.
If you ask long-time Richland County residents about pizza, Leaning Tower is one of the first names you hear. The pies lean toward a classic, slightly thicker crust with plenty of toppings and a sauce that tastes like it has been tweaked over decades. It’s the kind of place you go for a casual night out, a big pitcher of soda, and a pizza that feels reliably familiar.
02
Top carryout option
Deschner's Pizza
East Mansfield Near The Ashland Road Corridor • Carryout-Focused Pizza Shop • Best For Takeout And Game Nights
Neighborhood-style pies with a slightly sweet sauce and crisped edges, built for grabbing on the way home.
Deschner’s is the kind of low-key shop that keeps nearby households well-fed on busy weeknights. The crust lands between thin and hand-tossed, with a bit of crunch under a classic Ohio-style blend of cheese and toppings. Order ahead, pick it up hot, and you’re set for a couch-and-movie evening a few minutes from Roseland.
03
Downtown slice stop
Two Cousins Pizza
Downtown Mansfield • Classic Italian-American Pizzeria • Best For Groups And Casual Meetups
Hearty, shareable pies in the heart of downtown, ideal before a show or after an afternoon exploring Mansfield.
Two Cousins combines a straightforward menu with generous portions, making it a go-to when you’re feeding a crowd. Expect well-loaded pizzas with plenty of cheese and dependable standards like pepperoni, sausage, and veggie combinations. The central location makes it a convenient stop if you’re heading into town from Roseland for errands or a night out.
04
Creative pies and coffee
Pronto Pizza & Coffee
Ashland Road Area Southeast Of Roseland • Modern Pizza And Coffee Spot • Best For Inventive Combos
Handmade pies with thoughtful topping combinations, plus espresso drinks for a different take on pizza night.
Pronto stands out by pairing thoughtfully made pizzas with a full coffee bar, so you can grab a latte with your pepperoni. The crust leans artisanal, with a bit of chew and good browning, and the menu usually features a few more creative topping lineups alongside the classics. It’s a smart choice when you want something a little different without driving far from Roseland.
05
Go-to for thick crust
Scotty's Pizza
Central Mansfield On Marion Avenue • Detroit-Style Specialty Pizzeria • Best For Hearty, Cheesy Slices
Square, pan-baked pies with caramelized cheese edges and a comfort-food level of richness.
Scotty’s leans into Detroit-style and pan pizzas, so expect a thicker, airy crust with a crispy edge and plenty of cheese. The corner pieces with caramelized cheese are especially popular with regulars. When you’re in the mood for something substantial and don’t mind a few extra napkins, it’s worth the short drive from Roseland.