01
Best overall pick
Old Town Pizza
Zanesville Road In Roseville • Carryout And Delivery Pizza Shop • Go-To Choice In The Village
A long-running Roseville favorite known for generous toppings and reliable takeout.
Old Town Pizza is the place locals mention first when you ask where to get a pie in Roseville. The menu leans classic, with plenty of options for customizable pizzas, subs, and sides, all done in a straightforward, small-town style. Call ahead for carryout or delivery and you’ll see why it has such staying power in the village.
02
Classic Italian institution
Adornetto's Selected Italian
Downtown Zanesville • Sit-Down Italian Restaurant With Pizza • Classic Zanesville Institution
Old-school Italian comfort food with thin, crispy pizzas that draw fans from all over Muskingum County.
A short drive from Roseville, Adornetto's is a destination in its own right for anyone craving a more traditional dine-in experience. The pizzas come with a signature thin crust, plenty of cheese, and a sauce locals swear by, alongside pastas and hearty Italian mains. It’s a comfortable spot for lingering over a meal with family or catching up with friends after a day in town.
03
Best for families
Pizza Cottage
Maple Avenue In Zanesville • Casual Family Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups And Kids
A bright, family-friendly pizzeria with big booths, shareable pies, and a broad menu of crowd-pleasers.
Pizza Cottage offers the kind of relaxed, roomy dining room that makes it easy to bring the whole crew from Roseville. Pizzas range from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty combinations, with salads, wings, and appetizers to round out the table. It’s a dependable choice when you want plenty of options and a laid-back atmosphere after a ballgame or shopping trip.
04
Best for adults’ night out
Weasel Boy Brewing Company
Riverside Zanesville Warehouse District • Brewpub With Artisan Pizzas • Best For Craft Beer Pairings
House-brewed beer served alongside creative, stone-baked pizzas in a relaxed riverside space.
For a change of pace from classic takeout, Weasel Boy pairs small-batch beers with inventive pizzas in a cozy, repurposed warehouse. The crust is chewier and more rustic than standard delivery pies, with toppings that go beyond the usual pepperoni-and-cheese lineup. It’s an easy recommendation when you’re heading from Roseville to Zanesville for live music, conversation, and a more grown-up slice.
05
Most reliable late-night option
Domino's Pizza
East Zanesville Commercial Stretch • National Delivery Chain • Most Dependable Late-Night Delivery
Fast, customizable chain pizza that reliably delivers to the Roseville area when local spots are closed.
When the craving hits later in the evening or you need something predictable for a crowd, Domino's is the workhorse option within range of Roseville. The menu offers build-your-own pizzas, specialty pies, breads, and desserts with easy online ordering and tracking. It might not be the most unique choice on this list, but it earns its spot for consistency and convenience.