01
Best overall pick
Dewey's Pizza - Kenwood
Kenwood • Creative Sit-Down Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Inventive Pies
A few minutes south of Rossmoyne, Dewey's Kenwood nails the sweet spot between chef-driven toppings and an easy, family-friendly vibe.[1]
Dewey's is known around Cincinnati for its creative combinations and open-kitchen energy, and the Kenwood location is the closest full-service spot for Rossmoyne pizza nights.[1] Expect crisp, chewy crusts, seasonal specialty pies, and big salads that are as much a draw as the pizza. It works just as well for a casual date as it does for feeding a kids’ team after practice.
02
Classic Cincinnati choice
LaRosa's Pizzeria - Blue Ash
Blue Ash • Classic Cincinnati Family Chain • Best For Families And Big Groups
If you grew up in Cincinnati, the Blue Ash LaRosa's feels like the default neighborhood pizza joint everyone agrees on.
Just up the road from Rossmoyne, the Blue Ash LaRosa's is a reliable go-to when you need to feed a crowd without overthinking it. The thin, edge-to-edge toppings, sweet-leaning sauce, and party-cut slices are pure hometown comfort. With roomy booths, plenty of kids’ options, and easy carryout, it’s the kind of place that quietly becomes a weekly ritual.
03
Old-school Italian pick
Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta
Montgomery • New York-Style Pizzeria And Pasta House • Best For A Sit-Down Pizza Dinner
A short hop north of Rossmoyne, Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta brings a New York-leaning pie to a cozy Montgomery dining room.[2]
Named among the better pizza parlors in the Cincinnati area, Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta draws regulars for its foldable slices and generous whole pies alongside hearty red-sauce pasta plates.[2] The crust lands in that satisfying middle ground—thin but sturdy, with just enough chew to stand up to heavier toppings. It’s a strong pick when you want a full Italian sit-down meal and still make pizza the star of the table.
04
Neighborhood hidden gem
Trophy Pizza
Evendale • Neighborhood Craft-Pizza Counter • Hidden-Gem Pick For North-Side Locals
Tucked over in Evendale’s strip of small businesses, Trophy Pizza feels like the kind of low-key spot you only learn about from a friend.[2]
Cincinnati Magazine has flagged Trophy Pizza among the city’s standout parlors, and it fits the bill if you like a slightly thicker, sturdier crust with bold toppings.[2] It is more counter-service than full restaurant, but the pies travel well and make an excellent takeout option for Rossmoyne residents who don’t mind a quick drive west. Think hearty, game-night-friendly pizza rather than dainty gourmet slices.
05
Destination pizza outing
Two Cities Pizza Co.
Mason • New York And Chicago-Style Destination Pizzeria • Worth-The-Drive Splurge
A bit farther from Rossmoyne but still an easy drive up I-71, Two Cities turns pizza night into a full-blown outing with both New York and Chicago styles under one roof.[4]
Two Cities has earned regional buzz for its split personality menu, letting you choose between foldable New York slices and indulgent, casserole-deep Chicago pies without switching restaurants.[4] The space leans into a city theme, making it feel more like a fun night out than a quick grab-and-go stop. It’s the place you pick when you want to impress visiting friends—or settle a friendly debate about which style of pizza really wins.