01
Best overall pick
East of Chicago Pizza
Uhrichsville • Buffet-Friendly Regional Pizzeria • Best For Variety And Big Appetites
A local standby with thick-crust pies, hearty toppings, and a buffet that keeps everyone at the table happy.
If you are coming from Roswell, East of Chicago in Uhrichsville is one of the easiest places to please a mixed group. The menu runs from thick, edge-to-edge cheese pizzas to loaded specialty pies, plus wings, wedges, and a salad bar when the buffet is running. It is the kind of spot where teams, families, and hungry road-trippers can settle in and leave full.
02
Best delivery standby
Domino's Pizza
Downtown New Philadelphia • Carryout And Delivery Chain Shop • Reliable Late-Night And Delivery Option
Fast, predictable pizza with plenty of crust styles and sauces, ideal when you just want an easy delivery to Roswell or nearby.
For many Roswell residents, Domino's in New Philadelphia is the default number to call when nobody wants to cook. You can customize everything from crust and sauce to toppings, so it works just as well for a basic pepperoni as it does for a loaded specialty pie. The later hours and consistent delivery make it especially handy after games or long shifts.
03
Classic dine-in choice
Pizza Hut
West New Philadelphia • Family-Friendly Sit-Down Pizzeria • Best For Family Dinners And Pan Pizza Fans
A familiar red-roof experience with pan pizzas, breadsticks, and pitchers of soda that make lingering over dinner easy.
If you grew up on Pizza Hut, the New Philadelphia location scratches that classic pan pizza itch. The thick, buttery crust and nostalgia-factor make it a natural pick for family dinners, especially when you add breadsticks and a couple of pastas to the table. It is a straightforward, no-surprises option when you want to sit down and let someone else handle the dishes.
04
Best budget option
Little Caesars Pizza
North New Philadelphia • Value-Focused Grab-And-Go Counter • Top Pick For Quick, Cheap Takeout
Hot-N-Ready pizzas and crazy bread make this an easy stop when you need to feed a crowd on a tight budget.
Little Caesars in New Philadelphia is all about speed and value, which comes in handy when you are driving back toward Roswell with hungry passengers. The Hot-N-Ready pies mean you can be in and out in minutes, and the price point is friendly enough for big families or spur-of-the-moment get-togethers. Toss in an order of crazy bread and you are set for movie night.
05
Game-day go-to
Papa John's Pizza
Dover • Delivery-Focused Chain With Specialty Pies • Best For Customizable Game-Day Orders
Sauce-forward pies with plenty of topping combos and those signature garlic dipping cups, great for sharing around the TV.
When there is a big game on, Papa John's in Dover is a solid call from the Roswell area. The crust works well with lots of toppings, and the mix of specialty pizzas, wings, and sides makes it easy to cover everyone’s preferences with a single order. Do not overlook the garlic sauce and pepperoncini that show up in every box—they are part of the ritual for many regulars.